Québec Election 2026: what each party promises on cybersecurity, privacy protection and digital government

No party has presented a real cybersecurity plan for the October 5, 2026 election. What they propose is mostly digital government reform, with cybersecurity mentioned only in passing. The Parti Québécois is the only party proposing a body dedicated to cyber defense (Cyberdéfense Québec) and more resources for the Commission d'accès à l'information (CAI).[9] However, the Ministère de la Cybersécurité et du Numérique (MCN) and the Centre québécois de cybersécurité (CQCS) already exist, and the PQ does not specify what the new agency would do beyond them (see the PQ section). The CAQ is the only party to have put a figure on fighting cybercrime ($14M over four years).[1] That is about $3.5M per year for all of Québec. The PLQ proposes the most concrete fixes for SAAQclic-type project failures.[4] These fixes, however, target governance, costs and suppliers: they contain no security or privacy commitment (see the NIST audit of the PLQ). The PCQ's digital platform is the most detailed digital document of any party, but it is an efficiency plan that would relax Law 25 for small businesses.[2] Québec solidaire devotes one paragraph (p. 33) to AI and data localization: an AI regulatory framework based on transparency, privacy and copyright, and Quebecers' personal data « protégées et stockées au Québec ».[3] No agency, no budget and nothing on government cybersecurity (see the QS section). Climat Québec has no documented commitment in these areas, while the Parti vert du Québec proposes, among other things, Internet voting (see the NIST audit).

Executive summary

The main findings, grouped by theme. Each theme links to the corresponding row of the comparison table and to the party details.

Cybersecurity

  • PQ The only party proposing a body dedicated to cyber defense (Cyberdéfense Québec) for critical infrastructure, with no budget or timeline.[9]
  • PLQPCQCAQ Rely on better IT governance (in-house talent, transparency, fewer consultants) rather than a funded defensive capability.
  • No party addresses cybersecurity standards for critical infrastructure and Hydro-Québec, the CQCS, incident response or mandatory security testing.

Privacy and Law 25

  • PQ Increase the CAI's resources and reform the act respecting access to information and the protection of personal information.[9]
  • PCQ The only party that promises to relax Law 25 for small businesses, with « amendes plus équilibrées ».[2]
  • QS Principles only; CAQPLQ no documented commitment.

Public safety: cybercrime and surveillance

  • CAQ The only party to put a figure on fighting cybercrime: two police technology expertise hubs, $14M over 4 years.[1]
  • No party regulates facial recognition or police surveillance technologies.

Digital sovereignty and hosting

  • Consensus among the five main parties, but to different degrees: from « souveraineté numérique progressive » (PCQ) and data « stockées au Québec » (QS) to sovereignty enshrined in law (PQ).[2][3][9]
  • QS Personal data « protégées et stockées au Québec ».
  • PCQ « Souveraineté numérique progressive » by 2030–2031.
  • No party reconciles sovereign hosting with the fact that hyperscaler tools, including security tools, are mostly American.

Artificial intelligence

  • PLQ Regulation of AI « dans le domaine public et privé », based on transparency and « souple ».[4]
  • PQ Public and private regulatory framework (p. 23).[9]
  • QS Framework based on transparency, privacy and copyright.
  • PCQ Ethical AI governance for the state only (2026–2027).[2]
  • CAQ Accelerate the use of AI in the state.

IT project management

  • PLQ Legal and budgetary authority for the MCN, publication of the MCN's opinions on projects over $25M, contracts that allow switching suppliers.[4]
  • PCQ Public dashboards, pilot projects, annual timeline, but favors PPPs.[2]
  • CAQ A team led by the Premier; criticized over the SIFA overrun.[5]

Budgets and timelines

  • CAQ $14M over 4 years (cybercrime).
  • PLQ No investment line for digital reform; presented only as a source of savings (financial framework, Table 3).[11]
  • PCQ Announced net savings of $3.45 billion over 5 years, the only plan with an annual timeline.
  • PQQS No costing. All savings figures are the parties' own projections.

Impact on the cybersecurity industry

  • Bringing government IT back in-house (PLQ, PCQ, CAQ): increased demand for architecture reviews, penetration testing before go-live and AI red teaming.
  • Sovereign hosting requirements (the five main parties): an advantage for Québec suppliers and audit work.
  • The PLQ and PQ platforms are the most favorable to security work.

NIST audit: key findings

The party platforms were reviewed against NIST CSF 2.0, the NIST Privacy Framework 1.0 and the NIST AI RMF 1.0. See the full audit.

Scores by NIST framework
The scores measure coverage, not security. Detailed scorecard
CSF 2.0 /24
PF /20
AI /16
Logo: Parti QuébécoisPQ
7/24
4/20
5/16
Logo: Coalition Avenir QuébecCAQ
6/24
3/20
4/16
Logo: Parti libéral du QuébecPLQ
6/24
5/20
5/16
Logo: Parti conservateur du QuébecPCQ
5/24
5/20
5/16
Logo: Climat QuébecClimat
4/24
1/20
0/16
Logo: Québec solidaireQS
2/24
5/20
5/16
Logo: Parti vert du QuébecPVQ
3/24
2/20
6/16

No party reaches a repeatable level

The best CSF 2.0 total is 7/24 (PQ). RECOVER is empty in all seven documents, and DETECT is empty in six.

CRITICAL: the PVQ proposes Internet voting

A per-vote code «traçable et de manière anonyme». This contradicts NIST's assessment (NIST IR 7770, VVSG 2.0).

Security framed as ownership, localization and sovereignty

No party commits to encryption, identity assurance levels, incident notification or security clauses with suppliers.

AI: adoption without testing

Five of the six parties that address AI promote it or accelerate its adoption, and none commits to TEVV, bias testing or privacy testing.

At a glance

The PQ: the most substantial on cyber and privacy

Its Projet national (pp. 23–25) commits to creating Cyberdéfense Québec for critical infrastructure, increasing the CAI's resources, enshrining digital sovereignty in law, hosting data in Québec as a priority and favoring open-source software. None of this has a budget or a timeline, and part of it is framed around an independent Québec.

NIST AUDITBest CSF 2.0 total (7/24), but the PQ says what, not how: Cyberdéfense Québec has no mandate over operators, no reporting obligation, no budget and no timeline. Neither Respond nor Recover. PQ review

The PLQ and the PCQ: the most concrete on digital project governance

The PLQ proposes real legal and budgetary authority for the MCN, an in-house elite team within the Agence numérique Québec, publication of the MCN's opinions on projects over $25M, and anti-lock-in contracts.[4] The PCQ proposes public dashboards, sandboxes, a paid « expert numérique stratégique » status, open-source software, an annual timeline and announced savings of $3.45 billion. The PCQ is also the only party that promises to relax Law 25.

NIST AUDITThe PLQ gets the best governance score (GV 3), but no privacy or cybersecurity content beyond the name of the ministry. The PCQ states security by design with no owner, standard or indicator, and favors PPPs without clauses, audits or exit terms. PLQ review

All parties: common gaps

None addresses Hydro-Québec's cybersecurity or cybersecurity standards for critical infrastructure, the CQCS or the government incident response model, municipal cyber resilience, cyber support for SMEs, facial recognition or police surveillance technologies, or mandatory security testing. For security consulting firms, the most likely effect on demand is indirect: bringing government IT back in-house (PLQ, PCQ, CAQ) and sovereign hosting requirements (the five main parties).

NIST AUDITDETECT, RESPOND and RECOVER are empty across the board. No party commits to encryption, identity assurance levels, incident notification or security clauses with suppliers. Common gaps

The PVQ: a critical measure

The PVQ proposes Internet voting for the provincial election, with a per-vote code «traçable et de manière anonyme». This contradicts NIST's assessment. The PVQ also presents the densest set of online control measures: a cap of 5 h/week of online gaming for minors with mandatory age verification, a social media tribunal and a ban on polls during election periods.

NIST AUDITIt is the only measure, across all platforms, that jeopardizes the very integrity of the general election. Flagged measures
Cross-cutting finding: the parties name intentions and those responsible, but almost never the mechanism, resources, timeline or indicators. No party reaches a repeatable level (level 3 type) for any NIST function. See the scoring grid

1. Party platform documents

Party Main platform document(s) Digital and cyber source(s) used
PCQ
Éric Duhaime
Official documents page: https://conservateur.quebec/documents-officiels/ Document technique – Plateforme numérique, 11 pp.: https://conservateur.quebec/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/Plateforme_numerique_mise_en_page_PCQ.pdf (presented on September 5, 2026)
PLQ
Charles Milliard
Commitments page: https://plq.org/en/commitments/ (FR: plq.org/engagements/); financial framework: https://plq.org/PLQ_Cadre_financier.pdf « Transformation numérique » and « Encadrement de l'intelligence artificielle » sections of the commitments page; financial framework, Tables 2 and 3[11]
PQ
Paul St-Pierre Plamondon
Projet national: https://pq.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/PQ-PROPOSITION-PRINCIPALE-PROJET-NATIONAL.pdf §3.4 « Réguler l'IA » (pp. 22–23), §3.5 « Maîtriser notre avenir technologique » (pp. 23–25), §3.2 institutions (pp. 20–21)
QS
Ruba Ghazal / Sol Zanetti
Plateforme électorale 2026, 34 pp.: https://cdn.prod.website-files.com/6a58006e8d06c0d8d7cc521d/6ab01e99dcf871bb13392026_Plateforme.pdf (linked from quebecsolidaire.net) Block 7, « Encadrer l'IA et protéger notre souveraineté numérique » (p. 33); transparency and access to information (p. 32)
CAQ
Christine Fréchette
No consolidated platform PDF. Thematic commitment pages, the Plan économique, a platform for the Capitale-Nationale and the financial framework: https://coalitionavenirquebec.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/cadre-financier-v8-30-aout.pdf [5] « Poursuivra la modernisation de l'État » (September 2, 2026): https://coalitionavenirquebec.org/fr/blog/2026/09/02/lequipe-christine-frechette-poursuivra-la-modernisation-de-letat/; [5] « Protégera mieux les Québécois face à la nouvelle criminalité » (September 12, 2026): https://coalitionavenirquebec.org/fr/blog/2026/09/12/lequipe-frechette-protegera-mieux-les-quebecois-face-a-la-nouvelle-criminalite/ [1]
Parti vert du Québec
Alex Tyrrell
Le Nouveau Plan Vert 2026 (published September 2): https://www.pvq.qc.ca/2026/09/03/programme-2026-le-nouveau-plan-vert-2/ [6] Full PDF, 80 pp.: https://www.pvq.qc.ca/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/Programme-2026-Parti-VERT-du-Quebec.pdf. Internet voting (p. 44), social media tribunal and AI (p. 46), age verification for online gaming (p. 56).[13]
Climat Québec
Martine Ouellet
Platform launch press release (August 28): https://climat.quebec/2026/08/28/communique-climat-quebec-lance-sa-plateforme-electorale-et-presente-26-nouvelles-candidatures-de-partout-au-quebec/ [7] Nothing found. The 2022 platform mentions only high-speed internet in the regions.[8]

Notes on the documents

2. Side-by-side comparison

Legend
Specificmechanism, dollar amount or target
Vaguevague or statement of principle
Noneno documented commitment found

Visual overview of commitments

Computed from the 13 coded topics in the detailed table below (the Budget and Timeline rows are not coded).

Topic
CAQ
PLQ
PQ
QS
PCQ
Gov. cyber / MCN
V
P
P
V
Critical infrastructure
P
Law 25 / CAI
P
V
P
Digital identity
V
Health data
V
V
V
Data sovereignty
V
P
P
P
V
Artificial intelligence
V
P
P
P
P
Police surveillance
V
Cybercrime
P
V
Cyber workforce
V
P
V
V
P
SMEs / municipalities
V
P
V
P
Open-source software
P
P
IT project management
V
P
V
P
Number of topics per party (out of 13)
Logo: Parti QuébécoisPQ6 specific · 5 vague · 2 none
6
5
2
Logo: Parti conservateur du QuébecPCQ6 specific · 3 vague · 4 none
6
3
4
Logo: Parti libéral du QuébecPLQ6 specific · 2 vague · 5 none
6
2
5
Logo: Québec solidaireQS2 specific · 3 vague · 8 none
2
3
8
Logo: Coalition Avenir QuébecCAQ1 specific · 6 vague · 6 none
1
6
6

The PCQ's “specific” rating on Law 25 is a loosening, not a strengthening.

Detailed table

Scroll horizontally to see all parties. The topic column and the header stay visible.

Topic
CAQ
PLQ
PQ
QS
PCQ
Government cybersecurity / MCN governance Vague
A team reporting directly to the Premier would follow digital projects « du début à la fin » and would have to « veiller à mieux protéger les données des Québécois ».[5]
Specific
Make the MCN the central body with legal and budgetary authority over ministries' digital projects.[4]
Specific (no budget)
Create Cyberdéfense Québec, an agency « pour protéger les infrastructures critiques et lutter contre les cybermenaces » (p. 24).[9]
None Vague
Promises « sécurité accrue des données » (p. 2). Cybersecurity appears only as a required skill for the new expert status.[2]
Critical infrastructure / Hydro-Québec None
(sensitive data and « infrastructures importantes » remain in the public sector)[5]
None Specific (principle)
Cyberdéfense Québec covers critical infrastructure. Secure Internet networks « en s'inspirant de modèles… comme Hydro-Québec » (p. 24).[9]
None
(Hydro-Québec is mentioned only to protect it from privatization, p. 16)
None
Law 25 / CAI None None Specific
Increase the CAI's resources (p. 24). Reform the law on access to information and the protection of personal information (p. 20).[9]
Vague
AI rules based in part on « vie privée » (p. 33). « Accès réel à l'information », protection of whistleblowers (p. 32).
Specific (loosening)
« ASSOUPLIR LA LOI 25 », with a risk-based approach, simplified templates, lighter privacy impact assessments for small businesses and « amendes plus équilibrées » (p. 2)[2]
Digital identity (SQIN) None
(a government program already under way)
None Vague
« Poursuivre le déploiement d'une identité numérique unique et sécurisée » (p. 25)[9]
None None
(only a « guichet unique numérique » in 2028–2029, p. 7)
Health data / data sharing None Vague
Telehealth platform; AI to reduce paperwork in health care[4]
Vague
Make health system data « transparentes et accessibles » (p. 51)
None Vague
Interoperability between ministries (2029–2030), inspired by X-Road
Cloud / data sovereignty Vague
Keep sensitive data in the public sector.[5] Relies on the government's February 2026 sovereignty policy.[10]
Specific
A cloud strategy so that the State keeps control of its data and the intellectual property of publicly funded developments; contracts that allow switching vendors[4]
Specific
Enshrine digital sovereignty in law; local « souverains » data centers; priority hosting of data in Québec (p. 24)[9]
Specific (one line)
Personal data « protégées et stockées au Québec » (p. 33). The QS candidate in Sherbrooke, Stéphanie Vachon (September 23), calls for a provincial moratorium on new data centers and a generic BAPE.
Vague
« Souveraineté numérique progressive », including hosting, by 2030–2031 (p. 8). Rejects « mesures protectionnistes coûteuses » (p. 2).[2]
AI regulation / governance Vague
Accelerate the use of AI in government to automate certain repetitive tasks.[5]
Specific (principles)
A framework for AI « dans le domaine public et privé », based on transparency and « souple ».[4]
Specific
A regulatory framework for the public and private sectors (p. 23). Subsidies for AI adoption.[9]
Specific (principles)
A regulatory framework covering transparency, privacy and copyright; « l'humain au cœur » (p. 33)[3]
Specific (government only)
An ethical AI governance framework in 2026–2027, mandatory human oversight of « décisions à fort impact », a Bürokratt-style pilot project (p. 3, 7).[2]
Surveillance / police technology / facial recognition None
(the police hubs target online activity without privacy safeguards: see the NIST audit)
None None
(only an office against foreign interference, p. 21)[9]
Vague
Fight profiling, reduce police coercion (p. 28). No technology-specific rules.
None
Cybercrime / fraud Specific
Two police « pôles d'expertise technologique » (Montréal, Québec) against fraud, online recruitment of minors, radicalization and trafficking. $14M over 4 years.[1]
Vague
« Utilisation accrue de l'IA » against tax evasion and cybercrime, counted as revenue (financial framework, Table 2)[11]
None None None
Cyber workforce / training Vague
Modernized workplace training for AI-related skills; monitoring of changing occupations by the ISQ and the Pôle perspective emploi.[12] Not cyber-specific.
Specific
An « équipe d'élite en innovation numérique » within Agence numérique Québec, which « agira comme développeur interne »; transformation capacity brought back in-house, with less reliance on consultants.[4]
Vague
Programs in robotics and AI (p. 41)[9]
Vague
« rebâtira une expertise publique forte » (p. 32)
Specific
A « statut d'expert numérique stratégique » (architecture, AI, cybersecurity) with pay equivalent to the private sector and bonuses, exempt from the hiring freeze. Reassignment of staff to IT positions (p. 2–3).[2]
SMEs / municipalities Vague
Competition that allows SMEs to bid on government services[5]
Specific (procurement)
15% local preference margin, simplified calls for tenders; moratorium on any new paperwork for municipalities and SMEs[4]
Vague
Support the digital transition of SMEs (p. 41); end of the lowest-bidder rule (p. 40)[9]
None Specific
Easier access to public contracts for SMEs; regulatory sandboxes; lighter Law 25 requirements for small businesses[2]
Open-source software None
(the government's February 2026 policy promotes open-source software)
None Specific
« Prioriser… logiciels libres par l'Administration publique » (p. 24)[9]
None Specific
Encourage the use of and contribution to open-source software; X-Road as a model (p. 3); expanded use by 2028–2029[2]
IT project management (SAAQclic, SIFA, Gallant) Vague
A single team led by the Premier to follow projects « du début à la fin ».[5]
Specific
Publication of MCN opinions, including for any project over $25M; contracts that allow switching vendors, citing the SIFA example[4]
Vague
Tighter control of cost overruns; individual accountability of executives; more resources for the Auditor General (p. 20)[9]
None Specific
Cites the Gallant report throughout; program-based rather than project-based approach; pilot projects before large-scale rollout; public dashboards on costs and timelines; stopping projects that do not deliver; but also favors PPPs for digital projects (p. 3–4)[2]
Budget $14M over 4 years (anti-cybercrime hubs)[1] Digital reform appears only as a source of savings, with no investment line (financial framework, Table 3)[11] No costing No costing Announced net savings of $3.45 billion over 5 years; no detailed cost for security[2]
Timeline Not specified Not specified None None Annual plan, from 2026–2027 to 2030–2031 (p. 7–8)[2]

3. Party details

PCQ

An efficiency plan paired with a privacy trade-off

  • Stated objectives: put almost all government services online, « garantir une sécurité accrue des données » and save $3.45 billion over five years (net savings of $0M / $400M / $850M / $1,000M / $1,200M from 2026–2027 to 2030–2031).[2]
  • Three pillars:
    • Simplification. Includes attaching the CTEG (Conseil du trésor et de l'efficacité gouvernementale) to the digital agency and loosening Law 25.[2]
    • In-house expertise and « autonomie numérique ». Includes the strategic expert status, reskilling, open-source software and SME access to contracts.[2]
    • « Numériser intelligemment et protéger ». Includes AI in government with human oversight, sandboxes, dashboards and PPPs.[2]
  • Strength of the figures: the savings are projections based on McKinsey-style automation benchmarks and on examples from other countries. The document itself calls them an « estimation de travail ».[2]
  • What is missing: the security content is thin. Nothing on incident response, no role for the MCN or the CQCS, no testing requirements and no budget for security.
Net savings announced by the PCQ
In millions of dollars, per fiscal year. Total: $3.45 billion.
0
400
850
1,000
1,200
2026–27
2027–28
2028–29
2029–30
2030–31

PCQ digital charter

« Pour que ça marche, il faut… » (Annexe 4, p. 11)[2]
  1. Simplify before digitizing: There are far too many administrative processes and formalities in Québec. It makes more sense to reduce their number before paying to digitize them.
  2. Test before generalizing: Before generalizing a digital process, costs, timelines, quality, simplicity for the user and productivity must be tested and measured. Correcting or stopping a bad project makes more sense than spreading a failure.
  3. The digital by design principle: Digital should not be a layer added at the end of a project. It must be a way of thinking built into services from the design stage.
  4. Transparency: The costs, timelines and results of major digital projects must be public, clear and regularly updated. A watchful public imposes discipline and makes it possible to detect slippage before it becomes irreversible.
  5. A culture of continuous improvement: A digital service is never truly finished. It must be continuously tested, measured and improved rather than trying to plan everything in advance. Not everything can be planned from the start: that is too rigid.
  6. Accountability: Every project must have a clearly identified person in charge. Responsibility must never get lost in the bureaucracy. When a project goes off track, it must be known who answers for the decisions made. Accountability is an incentive to perform well.
  7. Strengthen interoperability: Where the law allows it, public bodies must share information among themselves rather than asking citizens for it again.
  8. Pragmatic digital autonomy: Québec must keep control of its data, its critical systems and its expertise. Excessive dependencies must be reduced by favoring Québec businesses, open standards and open source.
  9. Cybersecurity: The security of data and systems must be built in from their design and throughout their lifetime. Protections must be matched to the sensitivity of the data and the importance of the services.
  10. Care for the citizen: Quebecers must keep control of their data and understand how it is used. In addition, the digital transition must include human support for those who need help using the new services.

The highlighted principles (8, 9 and 10) concern sovereignty, cybersecurity and privacy. Text transcribed from the image on p. 11 of the PCQ document.

PLQ

Governance fixes aimed at the next SAAQclic

  • Authority: the MCN would become the central body responsible for the government's digital transformation, with « autorité légale et budgétaire » over ministries' projects.[4]
  • Transparency: publish the MCN's opinions on CAQ-era projects and on all future projects over $25M.[4]
  • Anti-dependency: keep the State's intellectual property over what it funds, pursue a cloud strategy that keeps the State in control of its data and write contracts that allow switching vendors.[4]
  • Agence numérique Québec: an « équipe d'élite en innovation numérique » that « agira comme développeur interne ». Size and budget not specified.[4]
  • AI: a framework for AI « dans le domaine public et privé », based on transparency and « souple ». Enforcement body and legal form not specified.[4]
  • What is missing: nothing on the CAI's resources or Law 25, and cybercrime appears only as a revenue line in the financial framework.[11] The reform is presented as a delivery capability, not as a security mandate.
PQ

The broadest cyber and privacy platform, with no costing

  • Section 3.5 commitments: Cyberdéfense Québec, more resources for the CAI, digital sovereignty enshrined in law, sovereign data centers, priority hosting in Québec, a preference for open-source software, continued rollout of digital identity, a platform regulator, a national digital literacy plan and participation in international cyber and data standards.[9]
  • Institutional commitments: reform of the law on access to information and the protection of personal information, and an office against foreign interference.[9]
  • What is missing: no costing and no timeline. Some measures are framed in terms of independence.[9]
  • Unresolved question: the relationship between Cyberdéfense Québec, the MCN and the CQCS is not addressed. This gap will determine whether the agency is a new capability or simply a new name.
QS

Principles only

  • Page 33 commitments: a regulatory framework for AI (covering transparency, privacy and copyright), and Quebecers' personal data « protégées et stockées au Québec ».[3]
  • What is missing: no agency, no budget and nothing on government cybersecurity.
CAQ

A campaign on its record, with a single costed cyber measure

Campaign commitments

  • Two police technology hubs against cybercrime, at a cost of $14M over 4 years.[1]
  • A single team led by the Premier to oversee digital projects and « mieux protéger les données ».[5]
  • Accelerated use of AI in government.[5]

Record items cited that are government actions, not campaign commitments

  • The government's February 2026 Énoncé de politique de souveraineté numérique: Nuage gouvernemental du Québec, sovereign data centers, open-source software.[10]

Third parties

Climat Québec: its 2022 platform (24 pp.) contains no cyber, privacy or AI content.[14] Parti vert du Québec: its 80-page platform proposes, among other things, Internet voting, an online gaming cap for minors with age verification and a social media tribunal.[13] See the PVQ review.

4. Expert analysis (security and IT perspective)

Key differences

  • Security as a function in its own right, or as a side effect of good IT management. The PQ is the only party that treats cyber defense as a distinct function of the state. The PLQ, the PCQ and the CAQ assume that better IT governance (in-house talent, transparency, fewer consultants) will produce better security. This is partly true, since SAAQclic was a governance failure, but it does not replace a funded defensive capability.
  • Privacy is the issue that divides the parties most clearly. The PQ would strengthen the regulator (the CAI). The PCQ would lighten the obligations of small businesses. All the others are silent. The PCQ's idea of a risk-based approach has merit, since tiered obligations are common elsewhere. The risk is that « amendes plus équilibrées » weaken enforcement of the law at the very moment AI adoption is increasing the amount of personal information processed. Yet the CAI received 444 confidentiality incident reports in 2023-2024, or about 1,000 since September 2022 based on a prorated estimate, and it has been able to impose administrative monetary penalties since September 22, 2023.[15]
  • Sovereignty is a consensus, but to different degrees. It ranges from « souveraineté numérique progressive » (PCQ) and data « stockées au Québec » (QS) to sovereignty enshrined in law (PQ).[2][3][9] No party reconciles sovereign hosting with the fact that hyperscaler tools, including security tools, are mostly American.

Strengths

  • The PLQ's plan to publish the MCN's opinions on projects over $25M, and its anti-lock-in contracts, are low-cost and enforceable.[4] They would have brought SIFA to light earlier.
  • The PCQ's expert status exempt from salary scales, its public dashboards and its pilot projects before rollout are sensible, and it is the only plan with a delivery timeline.
  • The CAQ's anti-cybercrime hubs address a real gap in law enforcement.

Weaknesses and feasibility

  • Budgets: $14M over four years for a provincial anti-cybercrime capability is not much.
  • PCQ savings: the $3.45 billion figure depends on large-scale AI automation. It runs up against the PCQ's own hiring freeze and its intention to favor PPPs, precisely the kind of risk-sharing mega-contract criticized by the Gallant report.[2]
  • Cyberdéfense Québec: it is neither funded nor defined. Without legal authority over public bodies and without a clear division of roles with the MCN and the CQCS, it adds a layer rather than a capability.

Gaps common to all parties

Cybersecurity of critical infrastructure and operational technology (OT), including Hydro-Québec and water services.
Mandatory incident reporting and response for public bodies.
Cyber resilience of municipalities and school service centers (recurring ransomware victims).
Support for SME cyber hygiene, separate from access to contracts.
Rules on facial recognition and police surveillance technologies.
Security of the SQIN and of digital identity.
Mandatory independent security testing before systems go live.
Cybersecurity education in elementary and high school: only the PQ (national digital literacy plan) and the PVQ (digital literacy and « sécurité numérique » at school) address it, with no program, target or budget (see the NIST audit).
An aging population in a society that runs on computing: only « accompagnement humain » for those who need help (PCQ, principle 10) and « l'humain au cœur » (QS) are mentioned, with no measure targeting seniors, including against online fraud.

What this means for Québec's cybersecurity industry

  • More government IT in-house: a PLQ, PCQ or CAQ win means more state IT in-house and fewer large integrators. This shifts demand toward specialized, verifiable work: security architecture reviews, penetration testing of projects before they go live and red teaming of AI deployments. The main integrators (CGI and others) are the most exposed.
  • Sovereign hosting (the five main parties): these requirements favor Québec-based suppliers and create audit work around reversibility and auditability.
  • Privacy work: a PCQ relaxation of Law 25 would reduce compliance demand from small businesses. A CAI funded by the PQ would increase demand related to enforcement.

Recommendation

For Québec penetration testing firms, the PLQ and PQ platforms are the most favorable to security work. The PLQ's transparency and in-house delivery model creates verifiable checkpoints, and the PQ's cyber defense agency, strengthened CAI and preference for Québec suppliers increase demand. The PCQ's plan helps with access to public procurement, but reduces privacy-related demand. After the election, advocate through the Réseau des grappes and professional associations for three measures that no party has promised:

  1. mandatory pre-deployment security testing for projects over $25M reviewed by the MCN;
  2. a funded cyber program for municipalities and the school network;
  3. OT security standards for Hydro-Québec and water services.

What the parties propose: cyber, privacy and AI, according to their own documents

A description of what the parties' own documents say about cybersecurity, security, privacy, digital government, AI and online control. This section accompanies the NIST audit, which scores the same documents against NIST; it describes the proposals. Prepared on 2026-09-30.

[PARTIES §1]1. At a glance

[PARTIES §2]2. Documents reviewed

Party Document (title as printed) Date Pages URL Where the relevant content is
Logo: Parti conservateur du QuébecPCQ «DOCUMENT TECHNIQUE» / «PLATEFORME NUMÉRIQUE» Not printed (URL path 2026/09) 11 PDF pages; p.11 is an image (transcribed) https://conservateur.quebec/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/Plateforme_numerique_mise_en_page_PCQ.pdf Entire document. Commitments: pp.1–4. Timeline: Annex 2, pp.7–8. Savings: Annex 3, pp.9–10. Charter: Annex 4, p.11
Logo: Parti libéral du QuébecPLQ Commitments web page; «Cadre financier 2026-2027 à 2030-2031» Undated web page; framework dated Sept. 13, 2026 Web page; framework PDF (Table 2 p.4, Table 3 p.5) https://plq.org/engagements/; https://plq.org/PLQ_Cadre_financier.pdf «Transformation numérique»; «Encadrement de l'intelligence artificielle»; Moderniser l'État; Santé; L'économie; framework Tables 2–3
Logo: Parti QuébécoisPQ «Projet national» Not printed (PDF created 2026-03-20) 90 PDF pages https://pq.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/PQ-PROPOSITION-PRINCIPALE-PROJET-NATIONAL.pdf §3.2–3.5 pp.20–25; §1.1 p.7; §2.2 p.14; §4.4 pp.39–41; §5.1.2 p.51; p.65; p.71; §5.5 pp.78–79
Logo: Coalition Avenir QuébecCAQ Campaign pages, «L'Équipe … Fréchette …» series 2026-09-02, 09-10, 09-12, 09-23, 09-26 Web pages See section 7 09-02 modernization (4 subheadings); 09-12 «S'attaquer au crime qui se déplace en ligne»; 09-10 AI and work; 09-26 screening IT; 09-23 youth mental health
Logo: Québec solidaireQS «PLATEFORME ÉLECTORALE 2026» Not printed (PDF created 2026-09-15) 35 PDF pages https://cdn.prod.website-files.com/6a58006e8d06c0d8d7cc521d/6ab01e99dcf871bb13392026_Plateforme.pdf Block 7 pp.31–33; Block 6 pp.27–28; Block 2 pp.9–10
Logo: Parti vert du QuébecPVQ «LE NOUVEAU PLAN VERT» / «PROGRAMME 2026» Not printed (PDF created 2026-09-03) 80 PDF pages; PDF p.36 is numbered “37” https://www.pvq.qc.ca/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/Programme-2026-Parti-VERT-du-Quebec.pdf p.15; p.27; p.29; p.35; PDF p.36; pp.43–49; pp.54–56; p.67
Logo: Climat QuébecClimat «Programme du parti» «Adopté au Congrès de fondation le 23 avril 2022» 24 PDF pages https://climat.quebec/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/Programme-Climat-Que%CC%81bec-2022.pdf ch.5 pp.19–22 (cl. 5.15.d, 5.16, 5.19–5.21)

[PARTIES §3]3. Side by side

“Not specified” cells state the search that supports them. Absences on the PLQ website are ≈.

3a. Security, governance and delivery

Topic Logo: Coalition Avenir QuébecCAQ Logo: Parti libéral du QuébecPLQ Logo: Parti QuébécoisPQ Logo: Québec solidaireQS Logo: Parti conservateur du QuébecPCQ Logo: Parti vert du QuébecPVQ Logo: Climat QuébecClimat
Government cybersecurity body or lead No cyber body. A team reporting to the Premier is to «veiller à mieux protéger les données des Québécois» [CAQ-2026-09-02, «En finir avec le fax», ¶1, s5]; 0 occurrences of “cyber” [CAQ-2026-09-02, page entière (texte vérifié), recherche plein texte] The MCN becomes «le responsable central de la transformation numérique» [PLQ-E, «Transformation numérique», b1]. Its security mandate is not specified [PLQ-E, page entière : «cybersécurité» seulement dans le nom du ministère (≈)] New «Cyberdéfense Québec» agency for critical infrastructure and cyber threats [PQ p.24, §3.5 «De cyberdéfense et gouvernance numérique», b1] Not specified [QS pp.1–35, recherche plein texte : 0 occurrence «cyber»] No cyber body. The CTEG works «en étroite collaboration avec l'agence du numérique» [PCQ p.2, «Axe 1 – Simplification», eng. 1, s3]; one «responsable» per project [PCQ p.11, Annexe 4, principe 6 «De l'imputabilité», s1]; 0 occurrences of “MCN”, “cyberdéfense” [PCQ pp.1–11] Not specified [PVQ pp.1–80, recherche plein texte : «cyber» 1 occurrence, p.55 «cyberintimidation»] Not specified [Climat pp.1–24, recherche plein texte : 0 occurrence «cyber»]
IT project governance and oversight A team reporting to the Premier monitors digital projects «du début à la fin», with resources pooled «au sein d'un seul organe» [CAQ-2026-09-02, «En finir avec le fax», ¶1, s3–s4] Legal and budgetary authority for the MCN [PLQ-E, «Transformation numérique», b1]; MCN opinions published for projects over $25M [PLQ-E, «Transformation numérique», b5, s2] «Encadrer davantage les dépassements de coût» in publicly funded projects [PQ p.20, §3.2 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :», b8]; more resources for the Auditor General [PQ p.20, §3.2 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :», b4] Not specified; only general public expertise [QS p.32, Bloc 7 «Donner le pouvoir au peuple», ¶3, s1] Test before scaling up [PCQ p.3, «Axe 3 – Numériser intelligemment et protéger», eng. 2, s2]; public dashboards [PCQ p.3, «Axe 3…», eng. 3, s2]; stopping failing projects in 2029-30 [PCQ p.8, «Annexe 2…», 2029-30 •5] A permanent team «de simplification des services publics» whose tasks include modernizing IT systems [PVQ p.43, «Réparer la bureaucratie et améliorer les services publics», ¶2, s1] The state «développera son expertise interne» [Climat 2022 p.22, ch.5, cl. 5.19, s1]
Data sharing and interoperability Not specified [CAQ-2026-09-02, page entière (texte vérifié), recherche plein texte : 0 occurrence «interop», «échange de données»] Not specified in the PLQ-E items reviewed (≈; no exact full-text search possible) Not specified [PQ pp.1–90, recherche plein texte : 0 occurrence «interop», «échange de données»]. Health data would be made «transparentes et accessibles» [PQ p.51, «En matière d'organisation des services, le Parti Québécois s'engage à :», b8] Not specified [QS pp.1–35, recherche plein texte : 0 occurrence «interop»] Share data «Lorsque la loi le permet» instead of asking citizens for it again [PCQ p.11, Annexe 4, principe 7 «Renforcer l'interopérabilité», s1]; «Renforcer l'interopérabilité entre ministères» in 2029-30 [PCQ p.8, «Annexe 2…», 2029-30 •3] Not specified [PVQ pp.1–80, recherche plein texte : 0 occurrence «interop»]. Computerizing the justice system is to «faciliter l'accès aux dossiers» [PVQ p.49, «Moderniser le système judiciaire», ¶1, s1] Not specified [Climat pp.1–24, recherche plein texte : 0 occurrence «interop»]
Digital identity / single window Not specified [CAQ-2026-09-02, page entière (texte vérifié), recherche plein texte : 0 occurrence «identité», «guichet»] Not specified [PLQ-E, page entière : 0 occurrence «identité numérique» (≈)] «identité numérique unique et sécurisée pour chaque citoyen» [PQ p.25, §3.5 «D'identité et culture numériques», b1] Not specified [QS pp.1–35, recherche plein texte : 0 occurrence «identité numérique», «guichet»] A «guichet unique numérique pour plusieurs services» in 2028-29 [PCQ p.7, «Annexe 2…», 2028-29 •2]; 0 occurrences of “identité” [PCQ pp.1–11] Not specified [PVQ pp.1–80, recherche plein texte : 0 occurrence «identité numérique», «guichet»] Not specified [Climat pp.1–24, recherche plein texte : 0 occurrence «identité numérique»]
Data sovereignty / hosting / data centers Essential services and «données sensibles» stay in the public sector [CAQ-2026-09-02, «Mettre l'État au défi de faire mieux», ¶2, s4] A cloud strategy so that the state remains «maître de ses données» [PLQ-E, «Transformation numérique», b3, s1] Sovereignty in law; «Encourager» local, sovereign data centers; «Prioriser» hosting «sur le territoire québécois» [PQ p.24, §3.5 «Ainsi, le Parti Québécois structurera plusieurs efforts en matière :», b1, b3, b4] Personal data «protégées et stockées au Québec» [QS p.33, Bloc 7 «Encadrer l'intelligence artificielle…», ¶3, s1] «souveraineté numérique progressive (hébergement, open source, expertise interne)» in 2030-31 [PCQ p.8, «Annexe 2…», 2030-31 •3] A five-year moratorium on new data centers, plus disclosure obligations for existing centers [PVQ p.15, «Moratoire de cinq ans…», ¶1, s1; ¶2, s2] The state «sera propriétaire des infrastructures entreposant ses bases de données» [Climat 2022 p.22, ch.5, cl. 5.19, s1]
Open-source software Not specified [CAQ-2026-09-02, page entière (texte vérifié), recherche plein texte : 0 occurrence «logiciel libre», «open source»] Not specified [PLQ-E, page entière : 0 occurrence «logiciel libre», «code source» (≈)] «Prioriser le développement et l'utilisation de logiciels libres» [PQ p.24, §3.5 «Ainsi, le Parti Québécois structurera…», b5] Not specified [QS pp.1–35, recherche plein texte : 0 occurrence «logiciel libre», «open source»] «UTILISER L'OPEN SOURCE» [PCQ p.3, «Axe 2 – Expertise interne forte et autonomie numérique», eng. 3, s1]; conditions for using open source in 2026-27 [PCQ p.7, «Annexe 2…», 2026-27 •6] Not specified [PVQ pp.1–80, recherche plein texte : 0 occurrence «logiciel», «open source»] «priorisera l'utilisation de logiciels libres et ouverts» [Climat 2022 p.22, ch.5, cl. 5.19, s1]
Vendors / procurement / dependency / PPP «Une saine concurrence» with the private sector, compared on «les façons de faire et les coûts» [CAQ-2026-09-02, «Mettre l'État au défi de faire mieux», ¶1, s1–s2] Contracts structured so that the state can switch vendors; SIFA example [PLQ-E, «Transformation numérique», b4, s1–s2]; fewer consultants [PLQ-E, Moderniser l'État › «Simplifier les façons de faire», b4] Abolish the lowest-bidder rule to favor Québec businesses [PQ p.40, §4.4 «Pour un nationalisme économique, le Parti Québécois aspire à :», b7]; make public the contracts awarded to private companies, in its list on health services [PQ p.51, «En matière d'organisation des services…», b2] Rebuild public expertise «pour contrer l'influence du privé» [QS p.32, Bloc 7 «Donner le pouvoir au peuple», ¶3, s1] PPPs «permis et favorisés» for digital projects [PCQ p.4, «Axe 3…», eng. 4, s1]; an end to dependence on consultants [PCQ p.2, «Axe 2…», ¶1, s2] Not specified [PVQ pp.1–80, recherche plein texte : 0 occurrence «fournisseur», «consultant»] Criticism of «impartition» (outsourcing) [Climat 2022 pp.19–20, ch.5 «Pour que l'État reprenne le contrôle de nos services publics», ¶1, s3]
Cyber and digital workforce Positions cut «sans … perdre une expertise stratégique» [CAQ-2026-09-02, «Réduire sans toucher aux services», ¶1, s2]; AI skills through the 1% law [CAQ-2026-09-10, «Moderniser la formation en entreprise», ¶1, s3] Transformation capacity brought back in-house [PLQ-E, Moderniser l'État › «Simplifier les façons de faire», b4]; an «équipe d'élite» within the Agence numérique Québec [PLQ-E, «Transformation numérique», b2] AI and robotics training [PQ p.41, §4.4 «Pour nos PME, moteur de notre économie, le Parti Québécois aspire à :» (introduction p.40), b13]; no cyber workforce item [PQ pp.1–90 : «cyber» 5 occurrences, toutes pp.24–25] General «expertise publique forte» [QS p.32, Bloc 7 «Donner le pouvoir au peuple», ¶3, s1] An «expert numérique stratégique» status that requires cybersecurity skills [PCQ p.2, «Axe 2…», eng. 1, s2], exempt from the hiring freeze [PCQ p.3, «Axe 2…», eng. 1, s4] Not specified. Only a school competency, «la sécurité numérique» [PVQ p.55, «Santé, bien-être et autonomie personnelle», ¶1, s4] In-house expertise [Climat 2022 p.22, ch.5, cl. 5.19, s1]
Cybercrime / police technology Two police technology hubs, in Montréal and Québec City [CAQ-2026-09-12, «S'attaquer au crime qui se déplace en ligne», ¶1, s1] AI against tax evasion and cybercrime [PLQ-CF p.4, Tableau 2, ligne «Lutte à l'évasion fiscale et la cybercriminalité»] «Mieux équiper technologiquement nos services de police» [PQ p.78, §5.5 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :», b7] Not specified [QS pp.1–35, recherche plein texte : 0 occurrence «cybercrim»; «polic» 1 occurrence, p.28, profilage] Not specified [PCQ pp.1–11, recherche plein texte : 0 occurrence «police», «cybercrim»] Not specified [PVQ pp.1–80, recherche plein texte : 0 occurrence «cybercrim»; «police» 11 occurrences (pp.10, 34, 36, 50), aucune sur la technologie] Not specified [Climat pp.1–24, recherche plein texte : 0 occurrence «police», «cybercrim»]
Stated amounts and timeline Hubs: «14 M$ sur quatre ans» [CAQ-2026-09-12, «S'attaquer au crime…», ¶1, s3]. Cuts: more than 2,900 positions by March 31, 2029, $507M net over five years [CAQ-2026-09-02, «Réduire sans toucher aux services», ¶2, s3]. The digital team: not specified Table 2 (revenue): tax evasion and cybercrime $50M / $75M / $125M / $150M, from 2027-28 to 2030-31 ≈ [PLQ-CF p.4, Tableau 2]. The telehealth line shows «—» [PLQ-CF p.5, Tableau 3]. MCN and Agency: not specified Not specified [PQ pp.20–25, recherche plein texte : 0 occurrence «million», «milliard», «$»] Not specified [QS p.33, recherche plein texte : 0 occurrence «million», «$»] Net savings of $0 / $400M / $850M / $1,000M / $1,200M, total $3,450M [PCQ p.9, «Annexe 3 – Justificatif économique», tableau]; year-by-year actions [PCQ pp.7–8, «Annexe 2…»] A «de cinq ans» (five-year) moratorium [PVQ p.15, «Moratoire de cinq ans…», ¶1, s1]. No digital budget [PVQ pp.15, 43–46, 54–56, recherche plein texte : 0 occurrence «million»] Not specified [Climat p.22, recherche plein texte : 0 occurrence «million», «$»]

3b. Privacy, AI, online control, elections and transparency

Topic Logo: Coalition Avenir QuébecCAQ Logo: Parti libéral du QuébecPLQ Logo: Parti QuébécoisPQ Logo: Québec solidaireQS Logo: Parti conservateur du QuébecPCQ Logo: Parti vert du QuébecPVQ Logo: Climat QuébecClimat
Privacy / Law 25 / personal data The same team reporting to the Premier is to «mieux protéger les données» [CAQ-2026-09-02, «En finir avec le fax», ¶1, s5]; 0 occurrences of “vie privée”, “Loi 25” [CAQ-2026-09-02, page entière (texte vérifié)] Not specified [PLQ-E, page entière : 0 occurrence «vie privée», «renseignements personnels», «Loi 25», «Commission d'accès» (≈)] More resources for the CAI [PQ p.24, §3.5 «De cyberdéfense et gouvernance numérique», b2]; reform of the law on access to information and the protection of personal information [PQ p.20, §3.2 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :», b6] Privacy («vie privée») is one of the principles of the AI framework [QS p.33, Bloc 7 «Encadrer l'intelligence artificielle…», ¶1, s2]; TAL records anonymized [QS p.10, Bloc 2 Mesure 3 «Mieux protéger les locataires», ¶1, s3] «ASSOUPLIR LA LOI 25» for SMEs, with lighter impact assessments [PCQ p.2, «Axe 1…», eng. 2, s1, s3] Data on violence against trans people collected «dans le respect de la vie privée» [PVQ PDF p.36 (imprimée 37), «Droits des personnes transgenres et des personnes non binaires», ¶2, s3] Not specified [Climat pp.1–24, recherche plein texte : 0 occurrence «vie privée», «renseignements», «données personnelles»]
AI in government (+ human oversight) AI to automate «certaines tâches répétitives» and free up staff time for tasks that require their judgment [CAQ-2026-09-02, «S'attaquer à la paperasse…», ¶2, s2] AI adopted «là où elle génère des gains de productivité mesurables» [PLQ-E, Moderniser l'État › «Simplifier les façons de faire», b3]; oversight not specified Promote Québec AI in «santé, éducation, justice» [PQ p.23, §3.4 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :», b4]; oversight not specified [PQ pp.1–90 : 0 occurrence «supervision humaine»] «Il maintiendra l'humain au cœur du système» [QS p.33, Bloc 7 «Encadrer l'intelligence artificielle…», ¶1, s3] Pilot assistant; «supervision humaine obligatoire sur les décisions à fort impact» [PCQ p.3, «Axe 3…», eng. 1, s3, s5]; broader AI rollout in 2028-29 [PCQ p.7, «Annexe 2…», 2028-29 •1] No item on AI adoption in government. Warns against the state's use of AI in political debate [PVQ p.46, «Intelligence artificielle, désinformation…», ¶1, s1] Not specified [Climat pp.1–24, recherche plein texte : 0 occurrence «intelligence artificielle», «IA»]
AI regulation (private sector) Not specified. Only labor-market monitoring of changing occupations, with AI named as one of the factors [CAQ-2026-09-10, «Mieux anticiper les métiers en changement», ¶1, s1–s2] An AI framework «dans le domaine public et privé», based on transparency, «souple» [PLQ-E, «Encadrement de l'intelligence artificielle», ¶1, s1–s2] A regulatory framework for the private and public sectors, ensuring that it «ne freine pas l'innovation responsable» [PQ p.23, §3.4 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :», b1–b2] A regulatory framework on transparency, privacy, intellectual property and copyright [QS p.33, Bloc 7 «Encadrer l'intelligence artificielle…», ¶1, s2] Not specified. The only framework item, «Définir le cadre de gouvernance de l'IA», appears in the government rollout timeline; its scope is not specified [PCQ p.7, «Annexe 2…», 2026-27 •4] Not specified [PVQ pp.1–80 : «intelligence artificielle» 8 occurrences (pp.15, 17, 29, 46, 54), aucune n'est une règle de l'IA pour le secteur privé] Not specified [Climat pp.1–24, recherche plein texte : 0 occurrence «intelligence artificielle»]
Online control (minors, age verification, content, platforms, disinformation) The police hubs target «recrutement de mineurs en ligne» and «radicalisation des jeunes» [CAQ-2026-09-12, «S'attaquer au crime…», ¶1, s2] The RACJ «accrédite et surveille» online gambling platforms («jeu en ligne»), with «protection des mineurs» rules [PLQ-E, Moderniser l'État › «Mieux encadrer les jeux en ligne et les marchés prédictifs», b1–b2] «la lutte contre la désinformation» [PQ p.25, §3.5 «De développement durable numérique», b3]; a platform regulator whose other stated tasks are Québec content, French and cultural diversity [PQ p.25, §3.5 «D'identité et culture numériques», b2] Policies «visant à freiner les discours masculinistes» (context: «en ligne») [QS p.28, Bloc 6 Mesure 4 «Protéger les droits des femmes…», ¶2, s1] Not specified [PCQ pp.1–11, recherche plein texte : 0 occurrence «mineur», «réseaux sociaux», «vérification de l'âge», «censure», «désinformation»] A 5 h/week gaming cap for minors, with age verification [PVQ p.56, «ENCADRER LES JEUX VIDÉO…», ¶2, s1–s2]; social media tribunal [PVQ p.46, «Création d'un tribunal administratif des réseaux sociaux», ¶2, s1]; content ban [PVQ p.35, «Lutter contre l'hypersexualisation des jeunes filles», ¶2, s2] Not specified [Climat pp.1–24, recherche plein texte : 0 occurrence «réseaux sociaux», «désinformation», «vérification de l'âge»]. Télé-Québec as the only state-owned internet news corporation [Climat 2022 p.20, ch.5, cl. 5.16.a]
Elections and voting Not specified [CAQ-2026-09-02 et CAQ-2026-09-12, pages entières : 0 occurrence «vote», «scrutin», «élection»] Not specified in the PLQ-E items reviewed (≈) Tighter identity and address checks, and a mandatory voter card for the next referendum [PQ p.7, §1.1 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :», b8, s1]; an office against interference [PQ p.21, §3.2 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :» (introduction p.20), b12] Mixed-member proportional voting system and voting at 16 [QS p.31, Bloc 7 «Donner le pouvoir au peuple», ¶1, s1–s2]; no online voting [QS pp.1–35 : 0 occurrence «par internet»] Not specified [PCQ pp.1–11, recherche plein texte : 0 occurrence «vote», «scrutin», «élection»] Internet advance voting [PVQ p.44, «Le vote par anticipation sur internet», ¶2, s1]; ban on polls during election periods [PVQ p.45, «Restriction des sondages d'opinion en période électorale», ¶1, s2] Not specified [Climat pp.1–24, recherche plein texte : 0 occurrence «scrutin», «par internet»]
Transparency / access to information Not specified [CAQ-2026-09-02, page entière (texte vérifié), recherche plein texte : 0 occurrence «transparen», «accès à l'information»] Publish every MCN opinion on CAQ-era projects [PLQ-E, «Transformation numérique», b5, s1] Reform of the access law [PQ p.20, §3.2 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :», b6] «donnera un accès réel à l'information gouvernementale» and will protect whistleblowers [QS p.32, Bloc 7 «Donner le pouvoir au peuple», ¶3, s1] Public dashboards covering «les coûts, les délais, l'avancement et les résultats obtenus» [PCQ p.3, «Axe 3…», eng. 3, s3] MNAs' expenses on «un portail internet» [PVQ p.48, «Dévoiler les dépenses des député-e-s», ¶1, s1]; lobbying meetings made public [PVQ p.47, «Mettre fin au lobbyisme secret», ¶1, s2] Transparency («transparence») named as a goal for the state [Climat 2022 p.20, ch.5 «Pour que l'État reprenne le contrôle…», ¶1, s4]

[PARTIES §4]4. Party by party

Logo: Parti conservateur du Québec4.1 PCQ: «DOCUMENT TECHNIQUE» / «PLATEFORME NUMÉRIQUE» (11 pp.)

What it proposes
  1. The charter as a framework. «Les dix principes clés de la Charte du numérique (voir fin du document) sont le cadre de référence du plan numérique du PCQ.» [PCQ p.1, «Vision», ¶4, s1]. The 10 principles on p.11 frame the entire plan. How they are applied or revised: not specified.
  2. Security by design. «La sécurité des données et des systèmes doit être intégrée dès leur conception et pendant toute leur durée de vie.» [PCQ p.11, Annexe 4, principe 9 «La cybersécurité», s1]. Protections must be «adaptées à la sensibilité des données et à l'importance des services» [PCQ p.11, Annexe 4, principe 9, s2]. Owner, standard and controls: not specified.
  3. Main promises. «Les données des citoyens seront gérées de manière sécuritaire, et leur vie privée sera respectée.» [PCQ p.1, «Vision», ¶2, s3]. Use of the fax «dans les ministères sera chose du passé» [PCQ p.1, «Vision», ¶2, s1]. One of the objectives is to «garantir une sécurité accrue des données des Québécois» [PCQ p.2, «Objectifs», b2]. No date is attached to the fax promise.
  4. Relax Law 25. «ASSOUPLIR LA LOI 25», on the grounds that several provisions «nuisent plus aux entreprises qu'elles protègent les citoyens» [PCQ p.2, «Axe 1 – Simplification», eng. 2, s1]. It proposes «une approche par niveau de risque, des gabarits simplifiés, des analyses d'impact allégées pour les petites entreprises et des amendes plus équilibrées» [PCQ p.2, «Axe 1…», eng. 2, s3], while maintaining «une protection suffisante des données sensibles» [PCQ p.2, «Axe 1…», eng. 2, s2]. Which provisions would change, and when: not specified. The timeline contains nothing on Law 25 [PCQ pp.7–8 : «Loi 25» 0 occurrence; occurrences seulement aux pp.2 et 10].
  5. Who leads. The CTEG «travaillera en étroite collaboration avec l'agence du numérique» [PCQ p.2, «Axe 1…», eng. 1, s3], and «Chaque projet doit avoir un responsable clairement identifié.» [PCQ p.11, Annexe 4, principe 6, s1]. The «agence du numérique» is mentioned only once and is not described [PCQ pp.1–11 : «agence» 1 occurrence, p.2].
  6. Expert corps. A new status that «nécessitera une expertise en architecture de systèmes, en intelligence artificielle et en cybersécurité» [PCQ p.2, «Axe 2 – Expertise interne forte et autonomie numérique», eng. 1, s2]. It comes with pay competitive with the private sector, performance bonuses [PCQ p.2, «Axe 2…», eng. 1, s3] and an exception to the proposed hiring freeze [PCQ p.3, «Axe 2…», eng. 1, s4]. It is created in 2026-27 [PCQ p.7, «Annexe 2…», 2026-27 •5]. Headcount: not specified.
  7. Less outsourcing, more autonomy. «Nous mettrons fin à la dépendance coûteuse aux consultants externes» [PCQ p.2, «Axe 2…», ¶1, s2], with an action in 2027-28 to «Réduire le recours aux consultants externes» [PCQ p.7, «Annexe 2…», 2027-28 •8]. It names «la capacité de changer de fournisseur» and reduced technical dependence [PCQ p.2, «Axe 2…», ¶2, s1], built «de façon progressive» [PCQ p.2, «Axe 2…», ¶2, s2]. Contractual mechanisms: not specified.
  8. Open-source software. IT teams «seront encouragées à utiliser des plateformes et à contribuer à des projets open source» [PCQ p.3, «Axe 2…», eng. 3, s1]. Terms of use are to be prepared in 2026-27 [PCQ p.7, «Annexe 2…», 2026-27 •6], with broader use in 2028-29 [PCQ p.7, «Annexe 2…», 2028-29 •4].
  9. PPP. «Les contrats de partenariat (partenariat public-privé) seront permis et favorisés pour les projets numériques» [PCQ p.4, «Axe 3 – Numériser intelligemment et protéger», eng. 4, s1]. Contract clauses, audit and exit: not specified [PCQ pp.1–11 : 0 occurrence «clause», «audit»].
  10. SME access to calls for tenders. It would simplify calls for tenders and «allégerons les critères administratifs» [PCQ p.3, «Axe 2…», eng. 4, s2]. Which criteria: not specified.
  11. AI in government. «Nous lancerons un projet pilote d'assistant IA similaire.» [PCQ p.3, «Axe 3…», eng. 1, s3] (similar to Estonia's Bürokratt, s2). «Tout déploiement d'IA devra respecter une gouvernance éthique stricte, la protection rigoureuse des données et une supervision humaine obligatoire sur les décisions à fort impact.» [PCQ p.3, «Axe 3…», eng. 1, s5]. The sequence:

    What counts as «fort impact» (high impact): not specified.

  12. Testing stage and sandboxes. «Aucune solution majeure ne sera déployée à grande échelle sans avoir d'abord été testée et validée dans des conditions réelles.» [PCQ p.3, «Axe 3…», eng. 2, s2]. Sandboxes for SMEs would operate «dans un cadre réglementaire allégé et sécurisé» [PCQ p.3, «Axe 3…», eng. 2, s1]. The testing criteria listed are «coûts, délais, qualité, simplicité pour l'usager et productivité» [PCQ p.11, Annexe 4, principe 2 «Tester avant de généraliser», s1]. Security criteria: not specified.
  13. Transparency and stopping projects. Each major project gets «un tableau de bord public» [PCQ p.3, «Axe 3…», eng. 3, s2], rolled out gradually from 2026-27 to 2028-29 [PCQ p.7, «Annexe 2…», 2026-27 •7; 2027-28 •6; 2028-29 •7]. In 2029-30, «Évaluer rigoureusement les projets et arrêter ceux qui ne livrent pas» [PCQ p.8, «Annexe 2…», 2029-30 •5].
  14. Inventory, data sharing, single window.
  15. Citizen control and sovereignty. «Les Québécois doivent garder le contrôle de leurs données et comprendre comment elles sont utilisées.» [PCQ p.11, Annexe 4, principe 10 «Se préoccuper du citoyen», s1]. «Renforcer la souveraineté numérique progressive (hébergement, open source, expertise interne)» comes in 2030-31 [PCQ p.8, «Annexe 2…», 2030-31 •3]. Mechanisms: not specified.
  16. Money. Net savings of $3,450M over five years ($0, $400M, $850M, $1,000M, $1,200M per year), with «coûts d'implantation pris en compte» [PCQ p.9, «Annexe 3 – Justificatif économique», ¶1 et tableau]. Implementation costs are not shown separately. The figure is «une estimation de travail destinée à être raffinée» [PCQ p.10, «Annexe 3…», ¶5 à la p.10, s1], and the timeline «sera ajusté» to the «Chantier gouvernemental de l'efficacité», if applicable [PCQ p.7, «Annexe 2…», note 2].
What the document does not say

How specific is it? Assessment: it is the only document with a dated delivery plan and a quantified target. Security and privacy remain at the level of principles, with no dedicated owner, criteria or budget. The only concrete privacy change is a relaxation. NIST scores: CSF 5/24, PF 5/20, AI RMF 5/16, with two Contrary items, both on relaxing Law 25 (tied to the burden on businesses and to their size) [NIST audit §3, §5.4].

Logo: Parti libéral du Québec4.2 PLQ: commitments web page and financial framework

What it proposes
  1. The MCN in charge. «Faire du ministère de la Cybersécurité et du Numérique (MCN) le responsable central de la transformation numérique gouvernementale» [PLQ-E, «Transformation numérique», b1]. The same bullet grants «l'autorité légale et budgétaire» to direct ministries' digital projects. Its security mandate and budget: not specified.
  2. In-house developer. An «équipe d'élite en innovation numérique» within the Agence numérique Québec that «agira comme développeur interne» [PLQ-E, «Transformation numérique», b2]. Size and budget: not specified on the page [PLQ-E : 0 occurrence «50 millions» (≈)].
  3. Cloud and intellectual property. «Adopter une approche stratégique en matière d'infonuagique afin que l'État demeure maître de ses données et de son architecture numérique.» [PLQ-E, «Transformation numérique», b3, s1]. The State is to own the intellectual property of developments funded with public money «autant que possible» [PLQ-E, «Transformation numérique», b3, s2]. Residency or contractual rules: not specified.
  4. Exit-ready contracts. «Structurer les contrats de manière à permettre à l'État de changer de fournisseur sans se retrouver captif d'une entreprise.» [PLQ-E, «Transformation numérique», b4, s1]. The example given is SIFA and «sa clause de résiliation de 175 millions de dollars» [PLQ-E, «Transformation numérique», b4, s2].
  5. Published opinions. All MCN opinions on projects launched under the CAQ would be published [PLQ-E, «Transformation numérique», b5, s1] and, going forward, the opinions «pour tout projet de plus de 25 millions de dollars» [PLQ-E, «Transformation numérique», b5, s2].
  6. Pragmatic AI and automation in the State. «Adopter l'intelligence artificielle de façon pragmatique, là où elle génère des gains de productivité mesurables» [PLQ-E, Moderniser l'État › «Simplifier les façons de faire», b3]. «Automatiser certains processus afin d'accélérer la prestation des services» [PLQ-E, Moderniser l'État › «Remettre le citoyen au cœur de la prestation de services», b2]. It adds data-driven continuous improvement [PLQ-E, Moderniser l'État › «Simplifier les façons de faire», b1] and less reliance on consultants [PLQ-E, Moderniser l'État › «Simplifier les façons de faire», b4]. Human review: not specified.
  7. AI oversight for both sectors. «Mettre de l'avant un encadrement de l'IA dans le domaine public et privé qui sera basé sur le principe de transparence.» [PLQ-E, «Encadrement de l'intelligence artificielle», ¶1, s1]. It would be «souple» and would make developers responsible for «une IA éthique» [PLQ-E, «Encadrement de l'intelligence artificielle», ¶1, s2]. The page also promises «un cadre éthique clair» for AI in public institutions and businesses [PLQ-E, L'économie › «Agir en intelligence artificielle et en transformation numérique», b1]. Enforcement body and legal form: not specified.
  8. Health technology. «Mettre en place une plateforme de télésanté.» [PLQ-E, Santé › «Faciliter l'accès aux soins de première ligne», b1, s1]. Its line in the financial framework shows no amount («—») [PLQ-CF p.5, Tableau 3, ligne «Mise en place d'une plateforme de télésanté»]. Digital tools and AI would reduce professionals' administrative time [PLQ-E, Santé › «Accès à la première ligne», b4 (≈)]. Privacy and security conditions: not specified.
  9. Online gambling («jeu en ligne»). The RACJ's mandate is expanded «afin qu'elle accrédite et surveille l'ensemble des plateformes de jeu en ligne actives au Québec» [PLQ-E, Moderniser l'État › «Mieux encadrer les jeux en ligne et les marchés prédictifs», b1]. Accredited platforms follow «règles strictes en matière de publicité, de prévention de la dépendance et de protection des mineurs» [PLQ-E, Moderniser l'État › «Mieux encadrer les jeux en ligne…», b2]. The same list adds an industry-funded addiction-prevention body (b3) and an AMF–RACJ mandate on prediction markets (b4) [PLQ-E, Moderniser l'État › «Mieux encadrer les jeux en ligne…», b3–b4]. Table 2 books «Encadrement du jeu illégal en ligne» at $320M / $330M / $340M / $350M ≈ [PLQ-CF p.4, Tableau 2]. How minors are identified: not specified.
  10. AI against tax evasion and cybercrime. «La lutte à l'évasion fiscale et la cybercriminalité, notamment par une utilisation accrue de l'IA» [PLQ-CF ≈p.3, texte]. The corresponding line appears on the revenue side: $50M / $75M / $125M / $150M from 2027-28 to 2030-31 ≈ [PLQ-CF p.4, Tableau 2, ligne «Lutte à l'évasion fiscale et la cybercriminalité»]. Which body, which data and which safeguards: not specified.
  11. Funding source. The commitments are «financés principalement par les économies découlant de la réforme de l'État (gouvernance, efficacité et numérique)» [PLQ-CF ≈p.2–4, texte]. Table 3 shows «Modernisation et efficacité de l'État» at 300 / 850 / 1,400 / 1,700 ≈ [PLQ-CF p.5, Tableau 3]. There is no investment line for the MCN or the Agence [PLQ-CF p.5, Tableau 3 : aucune ligne de ce type (≈)].
  12. Procurement (≈). Favor «la qualité et la valeur» over the lowest compliant bidder, and digitize «l'entièreté des procédures» [PLQ-E, L'économie › «Favoriser l'achat local par le gouvernement du Québec», positions des puces ≈].
What the document does not say (≈, web page)

How specific is it? Assessment: there are few items, but those dealing with governance are mechanisms: legal authority, contract structure and a $25M publication threshold. It is silent on what these mechanisms must deliver in terms of security or privacy. NIST scores: CSF 6/24 (GV 3, the best governance score of all parties), PF 5/20, AI RMF 5/16 [NIST audit §3, §5.3].

Logo: Parti Québécois4.3 PQ: «Projet national» (90 pp.)

What it proposes
  1. A cyber agency. «Créer une agence dédiée, Cyberdéfense Québec, pour protéger les infrastructures critiques et lutter contre les cybermenaces.» [PQ p.24, §3.5 «De cyberdéfense et gouvernance numérique», b1]. Its mandate over operators, its powers, budget and timeline: not specified.
  2. Regulator and privacy law. «Augmenter les ressources de la Commission d'accès à l'information (CAI)» [PQ p.24, §3.5 «De cyberdéfense et gouvernance numérique», b2]. The PQ would also «Réformer la Loi sur l'accès aux documents des organismes publics et sur la protection des renseignements personnels.» [PQ p.20, §3.2 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :», b6]. The amount and the direction of the reform: not specified.
  3. The overall objective. «il est crucial de renforcer la cybersécurité et la protection des données personnelles pour garantir la sécurité des citoyens» [PQ p.24, §3.5 «La souveraineté numérique : un pilier essentiel de l'indépendance», ¶2, s3].
  4. Digital sovereignty [PQ p.24, §3.5 «Ainsi, le Parti Québécois structurera plusieurs efforts en matière :», b1–b5]:

    The content of the law and the security requirements: not specified [PQ pp.20–25, recherche plein texte : 0 occurrence «chiffr», «authentif», «incident»].

  5. Digital identity. «Poursuivre le déploiement d'une identité numérique unique et sécurisée pour chaque citoyen» [PQ p.25, §3.5 «D'identité et culture numériques», b1]. Assurance level and alternatives: not specified.
  6. AI.
  7. Platforms, literacy, digital sobriety.
  8. Disinformation and interference. «Renforcer la participation citoyenne en ligne et la lutte contre la désinformation» [PQ p.25, §3.5 «De développement durable numérique», b3]. It would also create «un bureau indépendant de lutte à l'ingérence étrangère dans les processus démocratiques et d'un mécanisme permanent de veiller [sic] face aux ingérences» [PQ p.21, §3.2 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :» (introduction p.20), b12]. Resources and scope: not specified (see section 5).
  9. Freedom of expression. The PQ «s'engage fermement à protéger la liberté d'expression… sans crainte de censure ou de répression» [PQ p.21, §3.3 «Protéger la liberté d'expression au Québec», ¶3, s1], by means of a framework law whose listed measures target CEGEPs, universities, schools, public media, the public service and public institutions [PQ p.22, §3.3 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :», b1–b5].
  10. Project oversight and procurement.
  11. Police and security.
  12. Referendum identity checks. «des mécanismes de surveillance plus robustes et étendus sur l'identité, l'adresse de résidence principale de l'électeur», with a mandatory voter card and control of election spending [PQ p.7, §1.1 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :», b8, s1]. This targets the next referendum, not online voting.
  13. Screens and health data.
What the document does not say

How specific is it? Assessment: it covers the largest number of topics, with named bodies (Cyberdéfense Québec, the CAI, a platform regulator, an anti-interference office). Each item fits in a single bullet, with no mandate, amount or date. NIST scores: CSF 7/24 (the highest), PF 4/20, AI RMF 5/16, with one Contrary item (referendum identity checks) [NIST audit §3, §5.1].

Logo: Coalition Avenir Québec4.4 CAQ: 2026 campaign pages

What it proposes
  1. A digital projects team reporting to the Premier. It is presented in light of SAAQclic: «le gouvernement doit reprendre le contrôle des projets numériques» [CAQ-2026-09-02, «En finir avec le fax», ¶1, s2]. «Une équipe relevant directement de la première ministre réunira l'expertise nécessaire pour les suivre du début à la fin.» [CAQ-2026-09-02, «En finir avec le fax», ¶1, s3]. Resources are grouped «au sein d'un seul organe» [CAQ-2026-09-02, «En finir avec le fax», ¶1, s4]. The team is also to «veiller à mieux protéger les données des Québécois» and make room for AI in government processes [CAQ-2026-09-02, «En finir avec le fax», ¶1, s5]. Its relationship to the MCN, its size and budget: not specified [CAQ-2026-09-02, page entière (texte vérifié) : 0 occurrence «MCN»]. The subheading names the fax, but the paragraph states no measure on the fax [CAQ-2026-09-02 : «fax» 1 occurrence, l'intertitre seulement].
  2. An efficiency and AI team. A second team «consacrée à l'efficacité de l'État relèvera directement de la première ministre» [CAQ-2026-09-02, «S'attaquer à la paperasse et aux dédoublements», ¶1, s1], without «une nouvelle structure» [CAQ-2026-09-02, «S'attaquer à la paperasse…», ¶1, s2]. The rule is «une exigence ajoutée, deux retirées» [CAQ-2026-09-02, «S'attaquer à la paperasse…», ¶2, s1]. «Le recours à l'intelligence artificielle sera également accéléré pour automatiser certaines tâches répétitives» [CAQ-2026-09-02, «S'attaquer à la paperasse…», ¶2, s2], in order to free up time for tasks that require employees' judgment.
  3. Private-sector competition, with a public core. Public bodies would face «Une saine concurrence» where the private sector can provide the service [CAQ-2026-09-02, «Mettre l'État au défi de faire mieux», ¶1, s1]. Essential services remain public, «notamment lorsqu'il est question d'infrastructures importantes, de données sensibles» [CAQ-2026-09-02, «Mettre l'État au défi…», ¶2, s4]. What counts as «données sensibles» (sensitive data): not specified.
  4. Staff cuts. The objective is to abolish «plus de 2 900 postes additionnels d'ici le 31 mars 2029», for about $507M net over five years [CAQ-2026-09-02, «Réduire sans toucher aux services», ¶2, s3]. The health, education and higher education networks are exempt [CAQ-2026-09-02, «Réduire sans toucher…», ¶2, s4]. The positions disappear without losing «une expertise stratégique» [CAQ-2026-09-02, «Réduire sans toucher…», ¶1, s2]. An exception for IT or cyber: not specified.
  5. Police technology hubs. «deux pôles d'expertise technologique, à Montréal et à Québec» would bring together police expertise against cybercrime [CAQ-2026-09-12, «S'attaquer au crime qui se déplace en ligne», ¶1, s1]. Targets: «la fraude, au recrutement de mineurs en ligne, à la radicalisation des jeunes et au trafic illicite» [CAQ-2026-09-12, «S'attaquer au crime…», ¶1, s2]. Funding: «14 M$ sur quatre ans» [CAQ-2026-09-12, «S'attaquer au crime…», ¶1, s3]. Powers, tools and oversight: not specified [CAQ-2026-09-12, page entière (texte intégral vérifié) : 0 occurrence «données», «vie privée», «surveill», «Commission d'accès»].
  6. AI and work. Continuous monitoring of occupations by the Pôle perspective emploi and the ISQ [CAQ-2026-09-10, «Mieux anticiper les métiers en changement», ¶1, s2]. The training rules of the 1% law would be amended to encourage skills «dont l'intelligence artificielle» [CAQ-2026-09-10, «Moderniser la formation en entreprise», ¶1, s3].
  7. Screening IT. Modernized systems would make it possible to «inviter systématiquement les personnes admissibles, d'automatiser les rappels et de mieux suivre les résultats» [CAQ-2026-09-26, «Aller plus loin grâce à de meilleurs outils», ¶1, s2]. Privacy conditions: not specified (NIST audit §5.2, three passages).
  8. Social media as a factor in youth mental health. It names «les réseaux sociaux, où certains discours peuvent nourrir l'isolement» [CAQ-2026-09-23, «Mieux comprendre ce que vivent les jeunes», ¶1, s1] and proposes a commission on the mental health of 6- to 16-year-olds [CAQ-2026-09-23, «Mieux comprendre ce que vivent les jeunes», ¶2, s1]. There is no control measure.
What the documents do not say

How specific is it? Assessment: owners are named at the highest level (the Premier's teams), and the policing measure has a location, a target and a budget. The digital government items have no mandate, budget or date. NIST scores: CSF 6/24, PF 3/20, AI RMF 4/16 [NIST audit §3, §5.2].

Logo: Québec solidaire4.5 QS: «PLATEFORME ÉLECTORALE 2026» (35 pp.)

What it proposes
  1. An AI framework. It would be «basé sur les principes de transparence, de transition socioécologique ainsi que sur le respect de l'identité et de la culture québécoise, de la vie privée» as well as on intellectual property and copyright [QS p.33, Bloc 7 «Encadrer l'intelligence artificielle et protéger notre souveraineté numérique», ¶1, s2]. «Il maintiendra l'humain au cœur du système malgré le virage numérique.» [QS p.33, Bloc 7 «Encadrer l'intelligence artificielle…», ¶1, s3]. Responsible body, legal form and sectors covered: not specified.
  2. Conditional AI adoption. It would promote «un usage éthique de cette technologie pour accroître la productivité des entreprises et l'efficacité des services», while protecting jobs and supporting retraining [QS p.33, Bloc 7 «Encadrer l'intelligence artificielle…», ¶2, s1].
  3. Data stored in Québec. «leurs données personnelles soient protégées et stockées au Québec» [QS p.33, Bloc 7 «Encadrer l'intelligence artificielle…», ¶3, s1]. Whether this binds the public sector, the private sector or both: not specified.
  4. Anonymized tenant files. The TAL must protect tenants «notamment en anonymisant les dossiers» [QS p.10, Bloc 2 Mesure 3 «Mieux protéger les locataires» (titre p.9), ¶1, s3].
  5. A public registry of rents and landlords. «un registre public et national des loyers ainsi que des propriétaires» [QS p.9, Bloc 2 Mesure 1 «S'attaquer aux spéculateurs et reprendre le contrôle du prix des loyers», ¶4, s1]. It would show «l'identité des propriétaires». Limits on personal data: not specified.
  6. Transparency. It would rebuild public-sector expertise, «donnera un accès réel à l'information gouvernementale et protégera les lanceuses et lanceurs d'alerte» [QS p.32, Bloc 7 «Donner le pouvoir au peuple», ¶3, s1], and would impose a five-year lobbying ban on former elected officials [QS p.32, Bloc 7 «Donner le pouvoir au peuple», ¶3, s2].
  7. Online speech. «un gouvernement solidaire mettra en place des politiques publiques visant à freiner les discours masculinistes» [QS p.28, Bloc 6 Mesure 4 «Protéger les droits des femmes et l'accès à l'avortement», ¶2, s1]. It would also strengthen «l'application de la loi 101 dans le monde numérique» [QS p.27, Bloc 6 Mesure 3 «Célébrer notre culture et notre langue», ¶6, s2] and put in place «mécanismes de découvrabilité du contenu québécois» [QS p.27, Bloc 6 Mesure 3 «Célébrer notre culture…», ¶1, s1].
  8. Violent partners. «en rendant disponibles les antécédents judiciaires des conjoints violents, en renforçant leur surveillance» [QS p.28, Bloc 6 Mesure 4 «Protéger les droits des femmes…», ¶3, s1]. This is not an online measure (see section 5).
  9. Profiling and policing. QS «luttera contre leur profilage» [QS p.28, Bloc 6 Mesure 5 «Lutter contre le racisme et pour la solidarité», ¶1, s1]. It would review the scope of police intervention [QS p.28, Bloc 6 Mesure 5 «Lutter contre le racisme…», ¶1, s2].
  10. Democracy and work. A mixed-member proportional voting system and voting at 16 [QS p.31, Bloc 7 «Donner le pouvoir au peuple», ¶1, s1–s2]; citizen-initiated referendums [QS p.31, Bloc 7 «Donner le pouvoir au peuple», ¶2, s1]; a right to voluntary telework and to disconnect [QS p.31, Bloc 7 Mesure 1 «Retrouver le temps de vivre», ¶1, s1].
What the document does not say

How specific is it? Assessment: AI and data are treated as principles on a single page. The only mechanism is the anonymization of TAL files: one named body, one dataset and one technique. NIST scores: CSF 2/24 (the lowest), PF 5/20, AI RMF 5/16, with one Aligned item (anonymization) and one Contrary item (surveillance of partners) [NIST audit §3, §5.6].

Logo: Parti vert du Québec4.6 PVQ: «LE NOUVEAU PLAN VERT» / «PROGRAMME 2026» (80 pp.)

What it proposes
  1. Online advance voting. «le directeur général des Élections du Québec devrait mettre en place un programme qui permettrait de voter par anticipation sur internet» [PVQ p.44, «Le vote par anticipation sur internet», ¶2, s1]. The PVQ states that it «réduirait les risques de fraudes ou de défauts informatiques en générant un code unique par vote qui sera traçable et de manière anonyme» [PVQ p.44, «Le vote par anticipation sur internet», ¶2, s2]. Each party's platform would be available «directement sur le système de vote» [PVQ p.44, «Le vote par anticipation sur internet», ¶2, s3]. Online voting is optional, with in-person voting still available «en cas de problème technique» [PVQ p.44, «Le vote par anticipation sur internet», ¶2, s4]. Technology, security design, cost and date: not specified.
  2. Ban on polls. «Le Parti Vert du Québec propose d'interdire les sondages en période électorale» [PVQ p.45, «Restriction des sondages d'opinion en période électorale», ¶1, s2]. The heading says «Restriction» and the text says «interdire». Scope (publication or conduct) and enforcement: not specified.
  3. Online gaming cap for minors. «Pour les mineurs, un gouvernement Vert limitera l'accès aux jeux vidéo en ligne à un maximum de cinq heures par semaine» [PVQ p.56, «ENCADRER LES JEUX VIDÉO ET LIMITER LE TEMPS D'ÉCRAN POUR LES JEUNES», ¶2, s1]. Gaming is limited to 6 p.m. to 8 p.m. on Fridays, weekends and public holidays (same sentence). Providers «devront mettre en place des mécanismes de vérification de l'âge, et des systèmes technologiques permettant de faire respecter ces limites» [PVQ p.56, «ENCADRER LES JEUX VIDÉO…», ¶2, s2]. Minors are also excluded from games with «des niveaux élevés de violence» [PVQ p.56, «ENCADRER LES JEUX VIDÉO…», ¶3, s1], presented as «une question de santé publique» [PVQ p.56, «ENCADRER LES JEUX VIDÉO…», ¶3, s4]. Verification method, data rules and penalties: not specified.
  4. Social media tribunal. The text notes that decisions on «la surpression [sic] des comptes» and on violent, discriminatory and hateful content are left to private platforms [PVQ p.46, «Création d'un tribunal administratif des réseaux sociaux», ¶1, s2]. «Dans l'ère numérique, le Québec a le devoir de réglementer les réseaux sociaux et d'entendre des causes devant une justice spécialisée» [PVQ p.46, «Création d'un tribunal administratif…», ¶2, s1]. Composition, powers and procedure: not specified.
  5. Caution on government AI. Government use of AI «dans le débat politique soulève des inquiétudes importantes» [PVQ p.46, «Intelligence artificielle, désinformation et liberté d'expression», ¶1, s1]. «Les outils d'intelligence artificielle ne sont pas capables de comprendre parfaitement les nuances du langage, l'humour, la satire» [PVQ p.46, «Intelligence artificielle, désinformation…», ¶3, s2]. Heavy fines could push platforms to «supprimer excessivement des contenus» [PVQ p.46, «Intelligence artificielle, désinformation…», ¶3, s4]. The text reports that organizations fear the government will use AI «pour influencer ou discréditer certaines expressions politiques» [PVQ p.46, «Intelligence artificielle, désinformation…», ¶4, s1]. No rule is proposed.
  6. Content rules. Social media companies profit from the hypersexualization of young women, and the PVQ states that «cette pratique représente une exploitation sexualisée de mineurs et devrait être interdite» [PVQ p.35, «Lutter contre l'hypersexualisation des jeunes filles», ¶2, s1–s2]. The PVQ supports a requirement to disclose retouched photos [PVQ p.35, «Lutter contre l'hypersexualisation…», ¶3, s1]. It would limit online gambling advertising [PVQ p.67, «Lutte contre les dépendances ludiques», ¶1, s3].
  7. Data centers. «un moratoire de cinq ans sur l'autorisation de nouveaux centres de données» to protect Hydro-Québec, water and energy capacity against AI-driven demand [PVQ p.15, «Moratoire de cinq ans sur les nouveaux centres de données…», ¶1, s1]. Existing centers would face an eco-tax and mandatory standards [PVQ p.15, «Moratoire…», ¶2, s1] and would have to publish their electricity and water consumption data [PVQ p.15, «Moratoire…», ¶2, s2]. Municipalities would gain a right to refuse data centers [PVQ p.43, «Donner plus de pouvoir aux municipalités», ¶2, s1]. Public or government hosting needs: not specified.
  8. Public service IT. A permanent simplification team whose tasks include «moderniser les systèmes informatiques» [PVQ p.43, «Réparer la bureaucratie et améliorer les services publics», ¶2, s1]. It would accelerate «l'informatisation du système de justice afin de… faciliter l'accès aux dossiers» [PVQ p.49, «Moderniser le système judiciaire», ¶1, s1]. It supports the creation of a state-owned telecommunications operator, Telecom-Québec [PVQ p.27, «Création de Telecom-Québec», ¶1, s1]. Security requirements: not specified.
  9. Literacy and school. Civic, media and digital education to recognize disinformation and understand «le fonctionnement des algorithmes et de l'intelligence artificielle» [PVQ p.54, «Éducation civique, médiatique et numérique», ¶1, s1]. School should foster practical skills, including «la sécurité numérique» [PVQ p.55, «Santé, bien-être et autonomie personnelle», ¶1, s4]. Under a zero-bullying goal in schools, it lists «cyberintimidation» among the behaviors to take seriously from the first signs [PVQ p.55, «Objectif zéro pour l'intimidation et la violence», ¶1, s2].
  10. Privacy and transparency.
  11. AI and work. Productivity gains from AI and automation «doivent servir à améliorer la qualité de vie de la population active» [PVQ p.29, «Semaine de travail de 32 heures», ¶1, s2].
What the document does not say

How specific is it? Assessment: its control measures are specific about outcomes (5 hours, 6–8 p.m., five years, «interdire»), but leave the technology to others (the DGEQ, gaming companies). It has the largest number of measures flagged by the NIST audit. NIST scores: CSF 3/24, PF 2/20, AI RMF 6/16 (the highest, driven by the risk identification on p.46). It has five Contrary items, including online voting, rated CRITICAL [NIST audit §3, §4, §5.7].

Logo: Climat Québec4.7 Climat Québec: «Programme du parti» (2022, 24 pp.)

What it proposes
  1. Digital autonomy clause. «Pour garantir un maximum d'autonomie numérique… l'État priorisera l'utilisation de logiciels libres et ouverts» [Climat 2022 p.22, ch.5, cl. 5.19, s1 (1re proposition)]. The State «sera propriétaire des infrastructures entreposant ses bases de données» [Climat 2022 p.22, ch.5, cl. 5.19, s1 (2e proposition)]. It «développera son expertise interne et au besoin développera des applications» [Climat 2022 p.22, ch.5, cl. 5.19, s1 (3e proposition)]. Timeline, cost and security requirements: not specified.
  2. Critique of outsourcing. The State has been weakened by policies «d'impartition qui ont grandement affecté la qualité des services rendus» [Climat 2022 pp.19–20, ch.5 «Pour que l'État reprenne le contrôle de nos services publics», ¶1, s3]. It must improve «son agilité, son efficacité, sa compétence et sa transparence» [Climat 2022 p.20, ch.5 «Pour que l'État reprenne le contrôle…», ¶1, s4].
  3. Media and Internet access.
  4. Intellectual property of research. «S'assurera que les résultats de la recherche financée par l'État restent la propriété de l'État.» [Climat 2022 p.19, ch.5, cl. 5.15.d].
What the document does not say

How specific is it? Assessment: a single sentence of digital policy, written in 2022, with one concrete target (State-owned database infrastructure) and no means. NIST scores: CSF 4/24, PF 1/20, AI RMF 0/16 [NIST audit §3, §5.5].

[PARTIES §5]5. Online control and surveillance measures (flagged)

These measures are flagged because they involve online control or surveillance. The NIST audit gives their verdicts [NIST audit §4, §4.2]. Rows marked offline are included for completeness.

Measure Party + reference What the text says exactly What it leaves unspecified
Online advance voting Logo: Parti vert du QuébecPVQ [PVQ p.44, «Le vote par anticipation sur internet», ¶2, s1–s4] The DGEQ «devrait» put online advance voting in place. A per-vote code «traçable et de manière anonyme» would reduce fraud. Party platforms are on the voting system. Online voting is optional, with in-person voting as a fallback Voter authentication, how a code can be both traceable and anonymous, audit or paper trail, vendor, cost, date, and cancellation of an online ballot after a problem
Gaming cap + age verification Logo: Parti vert du QuébecPVQ [PVQ p.56, «ENCADRER LES JEUX VIDÉO…», ¶2, s1–s2] Minors limited to 5 hours/week of online games, from 6 p.m. to 8 p.m. on Fridays, weekends and public holidays. Providers «devront» deploy age verification and enforcement systems Verification method, data collected, retention and deletion, how playing time is counted across services, regulator and penalties
Ban on violent games for minors Logo: Parti vert du QuébecPVQ [PVQ p.56, «ENCADRER LES JEUX VIDÉO…», ¶3, s1] Excludes minors from games with high levels of violence, torture, cruelty or graphic violence Who rates the games; how minors are identified (same gap as above)
Social media tribunal Logo: Parti vert du QuébecPVQ [PVQ p.46, «Création d'un tribunal administratif des réseaux sociaux», ¶1, s2; ¶2, s1] Québec «a le devoir de réglementer les réseaux sociaux» and to hear cases before a specialized, accessible court that protects freedom of expression. The context is account deletion and violent, discriminatory or hateful content Jurisdiction over platforms, who can file a complaint, what powers (order removal? reinstatement?), procedure, what user data it handles
Ban on polls during election periods Logo: Parti vert du QuébecPVQ [PVQ p.45, «Restriction des sondages d'opinion en période électorale», ¶1, s2] «interdire les sondages en période électorale» Whether conducting or publishing is banned, the length of the period, online and foreign polls, penalties
Content bans and labeling Logo: Parti vert du QuébecPVQ [PVQ p.35, «Lutter contre l'hypersexualisation des jeunes filles», ¶2, s1–s2; ¶3, s1] Social media companies profiting from the hypersexualization of young women «devrait être interdite». The PVQ supports a requirement to label retouched photos Definition, who enforces, platform obligations, penalties
Police technology hubs (online targets) Logo: Coalition Avenir QuébecCAQ [CAQ-2026-09-12, «S'attaquer au crime qui se déplace en ligne», ¶1, s1–s3] Two hubs (Montréal, Québec City) pool police expertise against cybercrime and target fraud, online recruitment of minors, «radicalisation des jeunes» and illicit trafficking; $14M over four years Tools, legal powers, online data collected, retention, oversight body, what «radicalisation» covers
«lutte contre la désinformation» Logo: Parti QuébécoisPQ [PQ p.25, §3.5 «De développement durable numérique», b3] Strengthen online participation and «la lutte contre la désinformation» to protect public debate Means (literacy? monitoring? takedowns?), which body, and any link with the PQ's commitment against censorship [PQ p.21, §3.3 «Protéger la liberté d'expression au Québec», ¶3, s1]
Interference: «veiller [sic]» Logo: Parti QuébécoisPQ [PQ p.21, §3.2 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :» (introduction p.20), b12] An independent office against interference and «un mécanisme permanent de veiller [sic] face aux ingérences» What is monitored (online? people?), limits on data, oversight
Identity checks on referendum voters (offline) Logo: Parti QuébécoisPQ [PQ p.7, §1.1 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :», b8, s1] «mécanismes de surveillance plus robustes et étendus» on voters' identity and main address, a mandatory voter card, plus spending control; international observers (s2) What data, who checks it, retention, alternatives for voters without a card
Police technology (mostly offline) Logo: Parti QuébécoisPQ [PQ p.78, §5.5 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :», b3, b7] «moyens financiers, législatifs et technologiques» for police squads; «Mieux équiper technologiquement nos services de police» Which technologies, what legal powers, safeguards; a registry of criminal organizations is also proposed [PQ p.79, §5.5 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :» (introduction p.78), b12]
Curbing «discours masculinistes» Logo: Québec solidaireQS [QS p.28, Bloc 6 Mesure 4 «Protéger les droits des femmes et l'accès à l'avortement», ¶2, s1] In response to violent speech «tant en ligne que dans la vie de tous les jours», public policies «visant à freiner les discours masculinistes» Definition, means (education? moderation? legislation?), safeguards for rights
Surveillance of violent partners (offline) Logo: Québec solidaireQS [QS p.28, Bloc 6 Mesure 4 «Protéger les droits des femmes…», ¶3, s1] Make the criminal records of violent partners available and strengthen «leur surveillance» Who receives the records, on what trigger, what surveillance, retention
Licensing of online gambling, «protection des mineurs» Logo: Parti libéral du QuébecPLQ [PLQ-E, Moderniser l'État › «Mieux encadrer les jeux en ligne et les marchés prédictifs», b1–b2] The RACJ «accrédite et surveille» all online gambling platforms («jeu en ligne») (the operators, not the users); strict rules on advertising, addiction and «protection des mineurs» Whether protecting minors means age verification (not specified [PLQ-E : 0 occurrence «vérification de l'âge» (≈)]), data rules
AI detection of tax evasion and cybercrime Logo: Parti libéral du QuébecPLQ [PLQ-CF p.4, Tableau 2, ligne «Lutte à l'évasion fiscale et la cybercriminalité»; phrase ≈p.3] Fight tax evasion and cybercrime «notamment par une utilisation accrue de l'IA», booked as revenue ($50M to $150M/year ≈) Body, data sources, human review, safeguards on bias or privacy

The only dissenting voice. Only the PVQ describes how government AI surveillance fails. It states that AI tools do not grasp «l'humour, la satire» [PVQ p.46, «Intelligence artificielle, désinformation et liberté d'expression», ¶3, s2]. They can mistake «une opinion divergente, une erreur ou une critique politique» for disinformation [PVQ p.46, «Intelligence artificielle, désinformation…», ¶3, s3]. And fines can lead to excessive takedowns [PVQ p.46, «Intelligence artificielle, désinformation…», ¶3, s4]. The same page warns that «Toute régulation excessive de l'information peut fragiliser cet équilibre» [PVQ p.46, «Intelligence artificielle, désinformation…», ¶4, s3]. Assessment: this warning sits alongside the PVQ's own tribunal, poll ban and content ban, and the text does not reconcile them.

[PARTIES §6]6. Caveats

  • Web pages or PDFs. Quotes and absences for the PQ, QS, the PCQ, the PVQ and Climat come from exact searches of the local PDFs. The CAQ 09-02 page comes from text checked against a screenshot, and the CAQ 09-12 page from the full page text checked on 2026-09-30, which matches the two earlier WebFetch passes. The other CAQ pages and all PLQ text come from WebFetch passes.
  • ≈ items:
    • Bullet b4 of the PLQ's «Accès à la première ligne» and the positions of the buy-local bullets.
    • The PLQ-CF page of the sentence on «réforme de l'État» (p.2, p.3 or p.4 depending on the pass) and of the sentence on AI (≈p.3).
    • The column years and units of PLQ-CF Tables 2 and 3: a pass on 2026-09-30 read «en millions de dollars», with columns from 2026-27 to 2030-31 and the first year «—». Row values match from one pass to another.
    • All PLQ absence claims. A new keyword pass on 2026-09-30 missed text known to be on the page («mineurs», «consultants»); the PLQ's “0 occurrences” are therefore less robust than those from the PDFs.
    • The review of the roughly 45 CAQ pages.
  • Scope. The CAQ's 2026-02-13 page on digital sovereignty is excluded because it presents government policy. Climat has no text-readable 2026 platform, so its 2022 program is used. PDF p.36 of the PVQ is numbered «37».
  • NIST audit. Scores and verdicts are in the NIST audit (§3 scorecard, §4 flagged measures, §5 review by party). This section adds no scores.
  • Accuracy check (2026-09-30). An independent pass reread about 250 items against the party texts: 119 cells in section 3, 8 bullets in section 1, 7 document rows, about 100 list items and gap bullets in section 4, 15 rows in section 5 and the paragraph on the dissenting voice. PDF pages were re-extracted, and the PVQ's multi-column pages were read in layout mode or visually. The order of PLQ-E bullets, the PLQ-CF figures and the wording of the CAQ 09-10, 09-23 and 09-26 pages were rechecked with WebFetch. 23 items were corrected: 8 on the strength of the commitment or wording (e.g., the PVQ «appuie» Telecom-Québec, and does not commit to creating it; the CAQ's AI is meant to free up staff time, not to reserve judgment tasks for staff), 10 on scope (e.g., the PLQ's «jeu en ligne» means online gambling, not video games; the PQ's publication of contracts is in its health list; the CAQ's exemptions include higher education), 4 on the actor or detail (e.g., PVQ: social media companies profit from hypersexualization rather than engaging in it; the CAQ's teams report to the Premier rather than sitting in her office) and 1 on a location (PQ p.71 added to section 2). Three sentence ranges were widened along with other corrections. No amount, date or count was wrong.

[PARTIES §7]7. References

Party documents (sole source of evidence)
ID Document Date Pages URL
Logo: Parti conservateur du QuébecPCQ Parti conservateur du Québec, «DOCUMENT TECHNIQUE» / «PLATEFORME NUMÉRIQUE» Not printed (URL 2026/09) 11 https://conservateur.quebec/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/Plateforme_numerique_mise_en_page_PCQ.pdf
Logo: Parti libéral du QuébecPLQ-E Parti libéral du Québec, Engagements Web page, read on 2026-09-29 and 30 N/A https://plq.org/engagements/
Logo: Parti libéral du QuébecPLQ-CF PLQ, Cadre financier 2026-2027 à 2030-2031 Sept. 13, 2026 PDF (Table 2 p.4, Table 3 p.5) https://plq.org/PLQ_Cadre_financier.pdf
Logo: Parti QuébécoisPQ Parti Québécois, «Projet national» Not printed (PDF dated 2026-03-20) 90 https://pq.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/PQ-PROPOSITION-PRINCIPALE-PROJET-NATIONAL.pdf
Logo: Coalition Avenir QuébecCAQ-2026-09-02 «L'Équipe Christine Fréchette poursuivra la modernisation de l'État» 2026-09-02 Web page https://coalitionavenirquebec.org/fr/blog/2026/09/02/lequipe-christine-frechette-poursuivra-la-modernisation-de-letat/
Logo: Coalition Avenir QuébecCAQ-2026-09-10 «L'Équipe Fréchette veut mieux accompagner les travailleurs face aux transformations économiques» 2026-09-10 Web page https://coalitionavenirquebec.org/fr/blog/2026/09/10/lequipe-frechette-veut-mieux-accompagner-les-travailleurs-face-aux-transformations-economiques/
Logo: Coalition Avenir QuébecCAQ-2026-09-12 «L'Équipe Fréchette protégera mieux les Québécois face à la nouvelle criminalité» 2026-09-12 Web page. Checked against the full page text (2026-09-30): introduction ¶1–¶4, then 4 subheadings; ¶1 of «S'attaquer au crime qui se déplace en ligne» has 3 sentences (s1 hubs, s2 targets, s3 «14 M$ sur quatre ans»). The source prints «s'engage également a créer» (sic). https://coalitionavenirquebec.org/fr/blog/2026/09/12/lequipe-frechette-protegera-mieux-les-quebecois-face-a-la-nouvelle-criminalite/
Logo: Coalition Avenir QuébecCAQ-2026-09-23 «L'Équipe Fréchette investira 32,4 M$ pour améliorer la santé mentale des jeunes» 2026-09-23 Web page https://coalitionavenirquebec.org/fr/blog/2026/09/23/lequipe-frechette-investira-324-m-pour-ameliorer-la-sante-mentale-des-jeunes/
Logo: Coalition Avenir QuébecCAQ-2026-09-26 «L'Équipe Christine Fréchette misera sur le dépistage précoce pour sauver plus de vies» 2026-09-26 Web page https://coalitionavenirquebec.org/fr/blog/2026/09/26/lequipe-christine-frechette-misera-sur-le-depistage-precoce-pour-sauver-plus-de-vies/
Logo: Québec solidaireQS Québec solidaire, «PLATEFORME ÉLECTORALE 2026» Not printed (PDF dated 2026-09-15) 35 https://cdn.prod.website-files.com/6a58006e8d06c0d8d7cc521d/6ab01e99dcf871bb13392026_Plateforme.pdf
Logo: Parti vert du QuébecPVQ Parti vert du Québec, «LE NOUVEAU PLAN VERT» / «PROGRAMME 2026» Not printed (PDF dated 2026-09-03) 80 https://www.pvq.qc.ca/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/Programme-2026-Parti-VERT-du-Quebec.pdf
Logo: Climat QuébecClimat 2022 Climat Québec, «Programme du parti» Adopted April 23, 2022 24 https://climat.quebec/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/Programme-Climat-Que%CC%81bec-2022.pdf

NIST audit: the 2026 Québec party platforms miss the operational core of NIST

A review of the parties' documents against NIST CSF 2.0, the NIST Privacy Framework 1.0 and the NIST AI RMF 1.0. Prepared on 2026-09-30.

[NIST §1]1. Conclusion

[NIST §2]2. Method

  1. Documents (written by the parties only):
    • PQ «Projet national» (90 pp.)
    • QS «Plateforme électorale 2026» (35 pp.)
    • PCQ «Document technique – Plateforme numérique» (11 pp.)
    • PVQ «Le Nouveau Plan VERT» (80 pp.)
    • Climat Québec «Programme du parti» 2022 (24 pp.; no text-readable 2026 platform exists)
    • CAQ 2026 campaign pages on coalitionavenirquebec.org (~45 reviewed)
    • PLQ plq.org/engagements and financial framework (Sept. 13, 2026)

    Identifiers and URLs are listed in §8.

  2. Benchmarks (NIST only): CSF 2.0 (22 categories); Privacy Framework 1.0; AI RMF 1.0 + AI 600-1. Supplementary publications, used where directly relevant: SP 800-63-4, SP 800-53r5, SP 800-37r2, SP 800-61r3, SP 800-218, SP 800-188, NIST IR 7770 and VVSG 2.0.
  3. Score per function, from 0 to 4: 0 absent · 1 principle/slogan · 2 named target or owner (level 1 type) · 3 mechanism described (level 2 type) · 4 mechanism + resources + timeline + indicators (level 3 type).
  4. Per-statement verdicts: Aligned (mechanism consistent with the NIST outcome) · Partial (intent; outcome named, with no mechanism, owner or indicator) · Not addressed · Contrary (runs counter to the NIST outcome) · N/A (NIST provides no outcome).
  5. Evidence rule: party documents only (no press articles, laws, regulator reports, studies or government documents). Each finding cites a precise reference to the party document and a NIST identifier. Reference format: [DOC p.N, “section title as printed”, ¶/b/s]. The page is the one where the quoted sentence or bullet appears; when a section title or introduction («Le Parti Québécois aspire à :», QS measure titles) starts on an earlier page, the title is still cited for orientation (e.g., PQ §3.2 introduction p.20 → bullet p.21; QS «Mieux protéger les locataires» p.9 → text p.10; QS Bloc 6 Mesure 4 title p.27 → text p.28; QS «Donner le pouvoir au peuple» p.31 → text p.32; PQ «La souveraineté numérique…» p.23 → introductory bullets p.24).
    • PDF: [DOC p.N, “title”, ¶n/bn/•n, sN].
    • Web pages: [DOC-date, “subtitle”, ¶n, sN].
    • PLQ: [PLQ-E, «section», bN] or [PLQ-CF p.N, Tableau n].
    • Absence claims: [DOC pp.1–N: 0 occurrences of “term”…]. They come from an accent- and case-insensitive search of each page's text. Web absences come from WebFetch keyword checks and are marked ≈ when done in a single pass.

[NIST §3]3. Scorecard

The CSF 2.0 columns run from GV to RC, the Privacy Framework columns from ID-P to PR-P, and the AI RMF columns from GOV to MAN.

NIST CSF 2.0PRIVACY FRAMEWORK 1.0AI RMF 1.0
PartyGVIDPRDERSRCCSF /24ID-PGV-PCT-PCM-PPR-PPF /20GOVMAPMEASMANAI /16Aligned / Partial / Not addressed / Contrary
Logo: Parti QuébécoisPQ
21211ⁱ07020†114211150 / 31 / 20 / 1
Logo: Coalition Avenir QuébecCAQ
21102*06020013220043 / 10 / 4 / 0 (+1 N/A)
Logo: Parti libéral du QuébecPLQ
31101ⁱ06120115211153 / 13 / 4 / 0 (+3 N/A)
Logo: Parti conservateur du QuébecPCQ
22100051†1†1115211152 / 46 / 12 / 2
Logo: Climat QuébecClimat (2022)
2110004100001000000 / 5 / 1 / 0 (+2 N/A)
Logo: Québec solidaireQS
1010002012†115211151 / 10 / 9 / 1
Logo: Parti vert du QuébecPVQ
11†1*†0003011†002122*163 / 11 / 4 / 5 (+3 N/A)
  • * The score rests on a mapping by analogy:
    • CAQ RS: the police cybercrime hubs are mapped to RS.AN.
    • PVQ PR: «sécurité numérique» at school is mapped to PR.AT-01.
    • PVQ MEAS: disclosure of data centers' energy consumption is mapped to MEASURE 2.12.
  • † The function also contains a Contrary item. Scores measure coverage, not security.
  • ⁱ The score rests on implication only. No statement names an outcome in any category of the function, so §6 counts no category for it.
  • Changed in this audit: the PVQ's ID went from 0 to 1, so the PVQ's CSF went from 2 to 3. The same Partial ID.IM statement [PVQ p.43, «Réparer la bureaucratie et améliorer les services publics», ¶2, s1] was already checked in §6. The CAQ and the PLQ get ID 1 from ID.IM statements of the same strength.
  • Verdict counts come from each party's inventory. Row granularity differs by document, so compare counts within a single party, not across parties.

Score rationale. Each score is followed by the statement or statements that earned it, or by the zero-hit search behind a 0, together with the NIST identifier.

Party Framework Scores by function ← evidence ↔ NIST
Logo: Parti QuébécoisPQ CSF GV 2: named owners, with no budget or indicator [PQ p.24, §3.5 «De cyberdéfense et gouvernance numérique», b1–b2]; [PQ p.20, §3.2 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :», b4, b7]; sovereignty in law [PQ p.24, §3.5 «…structurera plusieurs efforts en matière :», b1] ↔ GV.RR-02/-03, GV.OV-01, GV.OC-03. ID 1: critical infrastructure and threats named, with no inventory [PQ p.24, §3.5 «De cyberdéfense et gouvernance numérique», b1]; [PQ p.23, §3.5 «La souveraineté numérique : un pilier essentiel de l'indépendance», ¶1, s2] ↔ ID.AM-05, ID.RA-03. PR 2: named targets [PQ p.25, §3.5 «D'identité et culture numériques», b1, b3]; [PQ p.24, §3.5 «…structurera plusieurs efforts en matière :», b2–b4] ↔ PR.AA-02, PR.AT-01, PR.IR-01, PR.DS-01. DE 1: «lutter contre les cybermenaces» [PQ p.24, §3.5 «De cyberdéfense et gouvernance numérique», b1]; «veille» (monitoring) of interference [PQ p.21, §3.2 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :» (introduction p.20), b12]; anti-drone technology [PQ p.79, §5.5 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :», b15] ↔ DE.CM-02, DE.AE-07. RS 1ⁱ: agency mission only [PQ p.24, §3.5 «De cyberdéfense et gouvernance numérique», b1]; [PQ pp.1–90 : 0 occurrence «notification», «signalement»; «incident» 1 occurrence, p.78, hors cyber] ↔ RS.MA, RS.CO; [SP 800-61r3]. RC 0: [PQ pp.1–90 : 0 occurrence «restaur», «continuité», «sauvegarde», «plan de reprise»] ↔ RC.RP, RC.CO.
Logo: Parti QuébécoisPQ PF ID-P 0: [PQ pp.1–90 : 0 occurrence «inventaire», «cartograph», «évaluation des facteurs», «EFVP»] ↔ ID.IM-P, ID.RA-P. GV-P 2: CAI given resources [PQ p.24, §3.5 «De cyberdéfense et gouvernance numérique», b2]; reform of the access and privacy law [PQ p.20, §3.2 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :», b6] ↔ GV.PO-P5, GV.MT-P7. CT-P 0†: Contrary expansion of voter identification [PQ p.7, §1.1 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :», b8]; tension around the «unique» identity [PQ p.25, §3.5 «D'identité et culture numériques», b1]; [PQ pp.1–90 : 0 occurrence «anonymis», «pseudonym», «consentement»] ↔ CT.DP-P, CT.DM-P. CM-P 1: [PQ p.20, §3.2 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :», b6] ↔ CM.AW-P1. PR-P 1: [PQ p.24, §3.5 «La souveraineté numérique…», ¶2, s3]; [PQ p.24, §3.5 «…structurera plusieurs efforts en matière :», b3] ↔ PR.DS-P1.
Logo: Parti QuébécoisPQ AI GOV 2: [PQ p.23, §3.4 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :», b1–b2]; [PQ p.22, §3.4 «Réguler l'intelligence artificielle au service du bien commun», intro, ¶1, s4] ↔ GOVERN 1.1, 1.2. MAP 1: [PQ p.22, §3.4 «Réguler l'intelligence artificielle au service du bien commun», intro, ¶1, s2]; [PQ p.23, §3.4 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :», b5] ↔ MAP 5.1. MEAS 1: [PQ p.25, §3.5 «De développement durable numérique», b1] ↔ MEASURE 2.12. MAN 1: [PQ p.23, §3.4 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :», b5] ↔ MANAGE 1.3.
Logo: Coalition Avenir QuébecCAQ CSF GV 2: [CAQ-2026-09-02, «En finir avec le fax», ¶1, s3–s4]; [CAQ-2026-09-02, «Mettre l'État au défi de faire mieux», ¶2, s4] ↔ GV.RR-01, GV.OV-03, GV.SC. ID 1: SAAQclic lesson [CAQ-2026-09-02, «En finir avec le fax», ¶1, s1–s2] ↔ ID.IM-01. PR 1: [CAQ-2026-09-02, «En finir avec le fax», ¶1, s5] ↔ PR.DS. DE 0: [CAQ-2026-09-02, page entière (texte vérifié) : 0 occurrence «cybersécurité», «surveill», «incident»]; [CAQ-2026-09-12, page entière (texte intégral vérifié) : 0 occurrence «surveillance»] ↔ DE.CM, DE.AE. RS 2*: [CAQ-2026-09-12, «S'attaquer au crime qui se déplace en ligne», ¶1, s1, s3] ↔ RS.AN (analogy), GV.RR-03. RC 0: [CAQ-2026-09-02, page entière : 0 occurrence «incident», «notification»]; no recovery item on the ~45 pages reviewed (≈) ↔ RC.RP.
Logo: Coalition Avenir QuébecCAQ PF ID-P 0: new processing, with no mapping [CAQ-2026-09-26, «Aller plus loin grâce à de meilleurs outils», ¶1, s2]; [CAQ-2026-09-26, page entière : 0 occurrence «vie privée», «renseignements»] ↔ ID.IM-P. GV-P 2: [CAQ-2026-09-02, «En finir avec le fax», ¶1, s5] ↔ GV.PO-P. CT-P 0: processing without controls [CAQ-2026-09-12, «S'attaquer au crime qui se déplace en ligne», ¶1, s2]; [CAQ-2026-09-26, «Aller plus loin grâce à de meilleurs outils», ¶1, s2] ↔ CT.DM-P, CT.DP-P. CM-P 0: [CAQ-2026-09-26, page entière : 0 occurrence «consentement», «confidentialité»]; [CAQ-2026-09-12, page entière : 0 occurrence «Commission d'accès»] ↔ CM.AW-P. PR-P 1: [CAQ-2026-09-02, «En finir avec le fax», ¶1, s5] ↔ PR.DS-P.
Logo: Coalition Avenir QuébecCAQ AI GOV 2: [CAQ-2026-09-02, «En finir avec le fax», ¶1, s5]; [CAQ-2026-09-02, «S'attaquer à la paperasse et aux dédoublements», ¶2, s2] ↔ GOVERN 2.1, 3.2. MAP 2: [CAQ-2026-09-02, «S'attaquer à la paperasse et aux dédoublements», ¶2, s2]; [CAQ-2026-09-10, «Mieux anticiper les métiers en changement», ¶1, s2] ↔ MAP 1.1, 5.1. MEAS 0 / MAN 0: no statement on testing, monitoring or deactivation [CAQ-2026-09-02, page entière (texte vérifié)]; other AI mentions concern skills or adoption [CAQ-2026-09-10, «Moderniser la formation en entreprise», ¶1, s3] ↔ MEASURE 2.x, MANAGE 4.1.
Logo: Parti libéral du QuébecPLQ CSF GV 3: authority, exit and published notices [PLQ-E, «Transformation numérique», b1, b4, b5]; retention of IP [PLQ-E, «Transformation numérique», b3, s2] ↔ GV.RR-01..03, GV.SC-10, GV.OV-01..03. ID 1: [PLQ-E, Moderniser l'État › «Simplifier les façons de faire», b1]; [PLQ-E, «Transformation numérique», b3, s1] ↔ ID.IM-01, ID.AM-07/-08. PR 1: [PLQ-E, «Transformation numérique», b3, s1] ↔ PR.DS. DE 0: [PLQ-E, page entière : 0 occurrence «cybersécurité» hors du nom du ministère, «protection des données» (≈ WebFetch, 2 passages)] ↔ DE.CM. RS 1ⁱ: [PLQ-CF p.4, Tableau 2, ligne «Lutte à l'évasion fiscale et la cybercriminalité»] ↔ RS.AN (implication). RC 0: same page check ↔ RC.RP.
Logo: Parti libéral du QuébecPLQ PF ID-P 1: [PLQ-E, «Transformation numérique», b3, s1] ↔ ID.DE-P. GV-P 2: [PLQ-E, «Encadrement de l'intelligence artificielle», ¶1, s1–s2]; [PLQ-E, Moderniser l'État › «Mieux encadrer les jeux en ligne et les marchés prédictifs», b1–b2] ↔ GV.PO-P. CT-P 0: [PLQ-E, Moderniser l'État › «Remettre le citoyen au cœur de la prestation de services», b2]; [PLQ-E, Santé › «Faciliter l'accès aux soins de première ligne», b1]; [PLQ-CF p.4, Tableau 2, ligne «Lutte à l'évasion fiscale et la cybercriminalité»]; [PLQ-E, page entière : 0 occurrence «vie privée», «renseignements personnels» (≈)] ↔ CT.DM-P. CM-P 1: [PLQ-E, «Encadrement de l'intelligence artificielle», ¶1, s1] ↔ CM.AW-P. PR-P 1: [PLQ-E, «Transformation numérique», b3, s1] ↔ PR.DS-P.
Logo: Parti libéral du QuébecPLQ AI GOV 2: [PLQ-E, «Encadrement de l'intelligence artificielle», ¶1, s1–s2]; [PLQ-E, L'économie › «Agir en intelligence artificielle et en transformation numérique», b1] ↔ GOVERN 1.1, 1.2. MAP 1: [PLQ-E, Moderniser l'État › «Simplifier les façons de faire», b3]; [PLQ-E, Santé › «Accès à la première ligne», b4 (≈)]; [PLQ-CF p.4, Tableau 2, ligne «Lutte à l'évasion fiscale et la cybercriminalité»] ↔ MAP 1.1. MEAS 1: benefit indicator only [PLQ-E, Moderniser l'État › «Simplifier les façons de faire», b3] ↔ MEASURE (benefit). MAN 1: [PLQ-E, Moderniser l'État › «Simplifier les façons de faire», b3] ↔ MANAGE 1.1.
Logo: Parti conservateur du QuébecPCQ CSF GV 2: [PCQ p.2, Axe 1 – eng. 1, s3]; [PCQ p.11, Annexe 4 – principe 6, s1]; [PCQ p.2, Axe 2 – eng. 1, s2]; [PCQ p.3, Axe 3 – eng. 3, s2]; capped by [PCQ p.4, Axe 3 – eng. 4, s1] and [PCQ p.10, Annexe 3, ¶4 à la p.10, s1] ↔ GV.RR-01/-04, GV.OV-01, GV.SC, GV.RM-03. ID 2: [PCQ p.7, Annexe 2, 2026-27 •1–•2]; [PCQ p.8, Annexe 2, 2030-31 •4] ↔ ID.AM-02, ID.IM-01. PR 1: [PCQ p.11, Annexe 4 – principe 9, s1–s2]; [PCQ p.1, Vision, ¶2, s3]; [PCQ p.2, Objectifs, b2] ↔ PR.PS-06, PR.DS. DE 0: [PCQ pp.1–11 : 0 occurrence «journal», «incident», «anomal», «menace»; «surveill» et «détect» 1 occurrence chacun = p.11 principe 4, s2, surveillance publique des projets] ↔ DE.CM, DE.AE. RS 0: [PCQ pp.1–11 : 0 occurrence «incident», «notification», «crise», «signalement»] ↔ RS.MA, RS.CO. RC 0: [PCQ pp.1–11 : 0 occurrence «continuité», «restaur», «sauvegarde»] ↔ RC.RP.
Logo: Parti conservateur du QuébecPCQ PF ID-P 1†: [PCQ p.7, Annexe 2, 2026-27 •1]; Contrary [PCQ p.2, Axe 1 – eng. 2, s3–s4] ↔ ID.IM-P1, ID.RA-P. GV-P 1†: [PCQ p.1, Vision, ¶2, s3]; [PCQ p.2, Axe 1 – eng. 2, s2–s3]; Contrary orientation [PCQ p.2, Axe 1 – eng. 2, s1] ↔ GV.PO-P. CT-P 1: [PCQ p.11, Annexe 4 – principes 7 et 10, s1] ↔ CT.PO-P, CT.DM-P. CM-P 1: [PCQ p.11, Annexe 4 – principe 10, s1] ↔ CM.AW-P. PR-P 1: [PCQ p.11, Annexe 4 – principe 9, s1]; [PCQ p.2, Objectifs, b2] ↔ PR.PO-P, PR.DS-P.
Logo: Parti conservateur du QuébecPCQ AI GOV 2: [PCQ p.7, Annexe 2, 2026-27 •4]; [PCQ p.3, Axe 3 – eng. 1, s5]; [PCQ p.2, Axe 2 – eng. 1, s2] ↔ GOVERN 1, 3.2. MAP 1: [PCQ p.3, Axe 3 – eng. 1, s2–s5]; [PCQ p.7, Annexe 2, 2027-28 •1] ↔ MAP 1.1, 5.1. MEAS 1: [PCQ p.3, Axe 3 – eng. 2, s2]; [PCQ p.11, Annexe 4 – principe 2, s1] ↔ MEASURE 2.5. MAN 1: [PCQ p.7, Annexe 2, 2027-28 •4]; [PCQ p.8, Annexe 2, 2029-30 •5] ↔ MANAGE 1.1, 2.4.
Logo: Climat QuébecClimat CSF GV 2: [Climat 2022 p.22, ch.5, cl. 5.19, s1]; critique of outsourcing [Climat 2022 pp.19–20, ch.5 «Pour que l'État reprenne le contrôle de nos services publics», ¶1, s3–s4] ↔ GV.RR-04, GV.SC. ID 1: [Climat 2022 p.22, ch.5, cl. 5.19, s1] ↔ ID.AM-08. PR 1: [Climat 2022 p.22, ch.5, cl. 5.19, s1] ↔ PR.IR. DE 0 / RS 0 / RC 0: [Climat pp.1–24 : 0 occurrence «cyber», «incident», «notification», «journalis», «sauvegarde», «continuité»; «surveill» 1 occurrence, p.22, qualité de l'eau] ↔ DE, RS, RC.
Logo: Climat QuébecClimat PF ID-P 1: [Climat 2022 p.22, ch.5, cl. 5.19, s1] ↔ ID.DE-P. GV-P / CT-P / CM-P / PR-P 0: [Climat pp.1–24 : 0 occurrence «vie privée», «renseignements», «données personnelles», «protection des données»] ↔ PF GV-P, CT-P, CM-P, PR-P.
Logo: Climat QuébecClimat AI All at 0: [Climat pp.1–24 : 0 occurrence «intelligence artificielle», «IA», «algorithm»] ↔ AI RMF GOVERN–MANAGE.
Logo: Québec solidaireQS CSF GV 1: [QS p.32, Bloc 7 «Donner le pouvoir au peuple», ¶3, s1]; [QS p.33, Bloc 7 «Encadrer l'intelligence artificielle et protéger notre souveraineté numérique», ¶3, s1] ↔ GV.RR-04, GV.SC-05, GV.OC-03. ID 0: [QS pp.1–35 : 0 occurrence «cyber», «inventaire», «gestion des risques»; «menace» 2 occurrences, hors cyber] ↔ ID.AM, ID.RA. PR 1: [QS p.33, Bloc 7 «Encadrer l'intelligence artificielle…», ¶3, s1] ↔ PR.DS-01. DE 0 / RS 0 / RC 0: [QS pp.1–35 : 0 occurrence «incident», «notification», «journalis», «sauvegarde», «continuité»; «surveill» 1 occurrence = élément Contraire p.28] ↔ DE, RS, RC.
Logo: Québec solidaireQS PF ID-P 0: [QS pp.1–35 : 0 occurrence «inventaire», «cartograph», «EFVP», «renseignements»] ↔ ID.IM-P, ID.RA-P. GV-P 1: [QS p.33, Bloc 7 «Encadrer l'intelligence artificielle…», ¶1, s2]; whistleblowers [QS p.32, Bloc 7 «Donner le pouvoir au peuple», ¶3, s1] ↔ GV.PO-P, GV.MT-P (analogy). CT-P 2†: [QS p.10, Bloc 2 Mesure 3 «Mieux protéger les locataires», ¶1, s3]; Contrary [QS p.28, Bloc 6 Mesure 4 «Protéger les droits des femmes et l'accès à l'avortement», ¶3, s1] ↔ CT.DP-P2, CT.PO-P. CM-P 1: [QS p.32, Bloc 7 «Donner le pouvoir au peuple», ¶3, s1]; [QS p.33, Bloc 7 «Encadrer l'intelligence artificielle…», ¶1, s2] ↔ CM.PO-P, CM.AW-P. PR-P 1: [QS p.33, Bloc 7 «Encadrer l'intelligence artificielle…», ¶3, s1] ↔ PR.DS-P.
Logo: Québec solidaireQS AI GOV 2: [QS p.33, Bloc 7 «Encadrer l'intelligence artificielle…», ¶1, s2] ↔ GOVERN 1.1, 1.2. MAP 1: [QS p.33, Bloc 7 «Encadrer l'intelligence artificielle…», ¶1, s1; ¶2, s1] ↔ MAP 5.1. MEAS 1: principles only [QS p.33, Bloc 7 «Encadrer l'intelligence artificielle…», ¶1, s2] ↔ MEASURE 2.8, 2.10, 2.12. MAN 1: [QS p.33, Bloc 7 «Encadrer l'intelligence artificielle…», ¶1, s3; ¶2, s1] ↔ MANAGE 1.3, GOVERN 3.2.
Logo: Parti vert du QuébecPVQ CSF GV 1: [PVQ p.43, «Réparer la bureaucratie et améliorer les services publics», ¶2, s1] ↔ GV.RR-02. ID 1†: the same team's IT modernization mandate [PVQ p.43, «Réparer la bureaucratie et améliorer les services publics», ¶2, s1] ↔ ID.IM; Contrary context [PVQ p.44, «Le vote par anticipation sur internet», ¶2, s2] ↔ ID.RA. PR 1*†: [PVQ p.55, «Santé, bien-être et autonomie personnelle», ¶1, s4]; [PVQ p.54, «Éducation civique, médiatique et numérique», ¶1, s1] ↔ PR.AT-01 (analogy); Contrary [PVQ p.44, «Le vote par anticipation sur internet», ¶2, s1, s3] ↔ PR.AA, [SP 800-53 CM-7]. DE 0 / RS 0: [PVQ pp.1–80 : 0 occurrence «notification», «authentif», «anomal»; «incident» 1 occurrence, p.76, animaux; «surveill» 10 occurrences, aucune liée à la surveillance des TI; «journalis» 5 occurrences = journalistes] ↔ DE, RS. RC 0: the in-person fallback is not a recovery plan [PVQ p.44, «Le vote par anticipation sur internet», ¶2, s4]; “restaur” 9 occurrences, outside IT ↔ RC.RP.
Logo: Parti vert du QuébecPVQ PF ID-P 0: [PVQ pp.1–80 : 0 occurrence «données personnelles», «renseignement», «EFVP», «évaluation des facteurs»] ↔ ID.RA-P. GV-P 1: [PVQ PDF p.36 (imprimée 37), «Droits des personnes transgenres et des personnes non binaires», ¶2, s3] ↔ GV.PO-P. CT-P 1†: [PVQ PDF p.36 (imprimée 37), «Droits des personnes transgenres…», ¶2, s3]; Contrary [PVQ p.56, «ENCADRER LES JEUX VIDÉO ET LIMITER LE TEMPS D'ÉCRAN POUR LES JEUNES», ¶2, s1–s2]; [PVQ p.44, «Le vote par anticipation sur internet», ¶2, s2] ↔ CT.DP-P, CT.DM-P. CM-P 0: the portals are accountability tools, not tools for awareness of processing [PVQ p.48, «Dévoiler les dépenses des député-e-s», ¶1, s1] ↔ CM.AW-P. PR-P 0: [PVQ pp.1–80 : 0 occurrence «protection des données», «authentif»; «chiffr» 2 occurrences, hors TI] ↔ PR.DS-P, PR.AC-P.
Logo: Parti vert du QuébecPVQ AI GOV 1: [PVQ p.46, «Intelligence artificielle, désinformation et liberté d'expression», ¶4, s1] ↔ GOVERN 1.1. MAP 2: [PVQ p.46, «Intelligence artificielle, désinformation et liberté d'expression», ¶3, s2–s5]; [PVQ p.29, «Semaine de travail de 32 heures», ¶1, s2] ↔ MAP 1.1, 5.1. MEAS 2*: [PVQ p.15, «Moratoire de cinq ans sur les nouveaux centres de données…», ¶1, s1; ¶2, s2] ↔ MEASURE 2.12 (analogy). MAN 1: [PVQ p.46, «Création d'un tribunal administratif des réseaux sociaux», ¶1, s2; ¶2, s1] ↔ MANAGE 4.1, MEASURE 3.3.
Key takeaways:
  • All parties cluster in GOVERN and part of PROTECT.
  • All parties score 0 for RECOVER. All but the PQ score 0 for DETECT; the PQ's DE 1 is implicit or physical.
  • The PQ and the PLQ lead on cyber governance.
  • The Privacy Framework's CONTROL-P is the weakest function everywhere.
  • The PVQ's apparent lead in AI reflects risk identification (MAP), not controls, and it sits alongside the largest number of Contrary items of any party.

[NIST §4]4. Measures flagged as harmful: online control, censorship, surveillance, Internet voting

The table covers online measures only; offline surveillance items are in §4.2. NIST verdicts follow the rubric. Where NIST offers no benchmark, the measure is still flagged as online control or censorship.

Measure Party + reference NIST basis (ID) Verdict Why (1 or 2 lines)
Internet voting (advance voting) Logo: Parti vert du QuébecPVQ: «un programme qui permettrait de voter par anticipation sur internet» [PVQ p.44, «Le vote par anticipation sur internet», ¶2, s1] [NIST IR 7770] [VVSG 2.0 Principles 9, 10] [SP 800-63-4] [CSF 2.0 PR.AA, PR.DS, ID.RA] Contrary: CRITICAL See the box below.
Online gaming cap for minors Logo: Parti vert du QuébecPVQ: «limitera l'accès aux jeux vidéo en ligne à un maximum de cinq heures par semaine» [PVQ p.56, «ENCADRER LES JEUX VIDÉO ET LIMITER LE TEMPS D'ÉCRAN POUR LES JEUNES», ¶2, s1] [PF CT.DM-P, CT.DP-P, ID.RA-P] [SP 800-53 PT-2, PT-3] Contrary: High A cumulative weekly quota requires recognizing the same minor across sessions and services, which implies persistent, linkable tracking. No privacy risk assessment is mentioned.
Mandatory age verification and control technology Logo: Parti vert du QuébecPVQ: «devront mettre en place des mécanismes de vérification de l'âge, et des systèmes technologiques» [PVQ p.56, «ENCADRER LES JEUX VIDÉO ET LIMITER LE TEMPS D'ÉCRAN POUR LES JEUNES», ¶2, s2] [SP 800-63-4 risk-based assurance, minimization] [PF CT.DM-P, CT.DP-P, GV.PO-P] Contrary: High Imposes new age-data collection for an entire category of services. No method, no retention or deletion rules, no attribute-only option (age predicate) and no proportionality criterion.
Minors barred from violent games Logo: Parti vert du QuébecPVQ: «interdira également l'accès des mineurs aux jeux vidéo contenant des niveaux élevés de violence» [PVQ p.56, «ENCADRER LES JEUX VIDÉO ET LIMITER LE TEMPS D'ÉCRAN POUR LES JEUNES», ¶3, s1] [SP 800-63-4] [PF CT.DM-P] Not addressed; flagged A content-based age control that depends on the same unspecified age verification.
Administrative tribunal for social media Logo: Parti vert du QuébecPVQ: «le Québec a le devoir de réglementer les réseaux sociaux» [PVQ p.46, «Création d'un tribunal administratif des réseaux sociaux», ¶2, s1] [AI RMF MEASURE 3.3, MANAGE 4.1] [PF GV.PO-P, CT.DM-P, GV.MT-P] Partial (intent); flagged NIST recognizes the value of appeal channels. But the tribunal is a state body that rules on the removal of accounts and content [PVQ p.46, «Création d'un tribunal administratif des réseaux sociaux», ¶1, s2], with no procedure, jurisdiction or data-handling design.
Ban on polls during the election period Logo: Parti vert du QuébecPVQ: «propose d'interdire les sondages en période électorale» [PVQ p.45, «Restriction des sondages d'opinion en période électorale», ¶1, s2] NIST: no applicable control (flagged) N/A; flagged (information restriction) Restricts the publication of information during the campaign.
Social media content bans and labeling Logo: Parti vert du QuébecPVQ: «représente une exploitation sexualisée de mineurs et devrait être interdite» [PVQ p.35, «Lutter contre l'hypersexualisation des jeunes filles», ¶2, s2]; mandatory label for retouched photos [PVQ p.35, «Lutter contre l'hypersexualisation des jeunes filles», ¶3, s1] [AI 600-1 Obscene, Degrading and/or Abusive Content; Information Integrity (analogy)] [PF CM.AW-P] Partial (intent); flagged A ban with no definition and no enforcement design. Enforcement implies content moderation by the platforms.
Limits on online gambling advertising Logo: Parti vert du QuébecPVQ: «Nous limiterons également les publicités des plateformes de jeux de hasard en ligne.» [PVQ p.67, «Lutte contre les dépendances ludiques», ¶1, s3] NIST: no applicable control (flagged) N/A; flagged (minor) Restriction of online advertising.
Police technology hubs targeting online activity Logo: Coalition Avenir QuébecCAQ: «s'attaquer davantage à la fraude, au recrutement de mineurs en ligne, à la radicalisation des jeunes» [CAQ-2026-09-12, «S'attaquer au crime qui se déplace en ligne», ¶1, s2] [PF GV.PO-P, CT.DM-P, CM.AW-P, GV.MT-P] [SP 800-53 PT-2, PT-3, AU-2, AU-6] [AI RMF GOVERN 1.1] Not addressed (oversight): High Police monitoring of online activity, including a speech-adjacent category («radicalisation»). The page mentions no legal basis, no purpose limitation, no retention, no audit and no oversight body [CAQ-2026-09-12, page entière (texte intégral vérifié) : 0 occurrence «vie privée», «surveillance», «données», «Commission d'accès»].
AI detection of tax evasion and cybercrime Logo: Parti libéral du QuébecPLQ: «La lutte à l'évasion fiscale et la cybercriminalité, notamment par une utilisation accrue de l'IA» [PLQ-CF p.4, Tableau 2, ligne «Lutte à l'évasion fiscale et la cybercriminalité»; phrase ≈p.3] [AI RMF MEASURE 2.10, 2.11, GOVERN 3.2] [SP 800-53 PT-2, PT-3] Not addressed (AI governance); flagged State AI analytics on personal tax data, booked as revenue, with no safeguard regarding bias, privacy or human review.
Accreditation of online gambling («jeu en ligne») and «protection des mineurs» Logo: Parti libéral du QuébecPLQ: «accrédite et surveille l'ensemble des plateformes de jeu en ligne actives au Québec» [PLQ-E, Moderniser l'État › «Mieux encadrer les jeux en ligne et les marchés prédictifs», b1]; «règles strictes en matière de publicité, de prévention de la dépendance et de protection des mineurs» [PLQ-E, Moderniser l'État › «Mieux encadrer les jeux en ligne et les marchés prédictifs», b2] [SP 800-63-4] [PF CT.DM-P, ID.DE-P] Partial (intent); to watch «Surveille» (“monitors”) targets operators, not users. The text does not mention age verification [PLQ-E, page entière : 0 occurrence «vérification de l'âge»]. If «protection des mineurs» is implemented through age verification, the proportionality and attribute minimization of SP 800-63-4 would apply, and the PLQ is silent on both.
«Lutte contre la désinformation» (fight against disinformation) Logo: Parti QuébécoisPQ: «la lutte contre la désinformation, afin de protéger la qualité du débat public» [PQ p.25, §3.5 «De développement durable numérique», b3] [AI 600-1 Information Integrity] [AI RMF MAP 5.1] [PF CT.DP-P, CM.AW-P] Partial (intent); flagged The means are not specified and could range from literacy to content monitoring. The measure is not linked to the PQ's commitment against censorship [PQ p.21, §3.3 «Protéger la liberté d'expression au Québec», ¶3, s1].
Permanent «veille» (monitoring) of foreign interference Logo: Parti QuébécoisPQ: «un mécanisme permanent de veiller [sic] face aux ingérences» [PQ p.21, §3.2 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :» (introduction à la p.20; puce à la p.21), b12] [CSF 2.0 ID.RA-02/-03, DE.AE] [PF CT.DP-P, CM.AW-P] Partial (intent); flagged A permanent monitoring function whose scope (online? of individuals?) and data limits are not specified.
Platform regulator and CRTQ Logo: Parti QuébécoisPQ: «réglementer les plateformes numériques, de promouvoir les contenus québécois» [PQ p.25, §3.5 «D'identité et culture numériques», b2]; «reprendre le contrôle de notre espace culturel et numérique» [PQ p.14, §2.2 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :» (introduction p.12), 3e puce à la p.14] [CSF 2.0 GV.OC-03] Not addressed; to watch (low) The mandate is cultural and linguistic. No power over user data or moderation is mentioned.
Curbing online speech Logo: Québec solidaireQS: «mettra en place des politiques publiques visant à freiner les discours masculinistes» (context: «en ligne») [QS p.28, Bloc 6 Mesure 4 «Protéger les droits des femmes et l'accès à l'avortement», ¶2, s1] [PF CT.DP-P, CM.AW-P] [AI 600-1 Information Integrity; Dangerous, Violent, or Hateful Content] Partial (intent); flagged Curbing online speech, with no specified means and no safeguard for rights.
Enforcement of Bill 101 online Logo: Québec solidaireQS: «renforcera l'application de la loi 101 dans le monde numérique» [QS p.27, Bloc 6 Mesure 3 «Célébrer notre culture et notre langue», ¶6, s2] [PF CM.AW-P] Not addressed; flagged (minor) Online language enforcement, with no specified means.

4.1 Items recognized as aligned or protective

4.2 Other forms of surveillance and data expansion (outside online censorship)

Item Reference NIST basis Verdict
Referendum voter identity checks «plus robustes et étendus» and a mandatory voter card «mécanismes de surveillance plus robustes et étendus sur l'identité, l'adresse de résidence principale de l'électeur» [PQ p.7, §1.1 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :», b8, s1] [PF CT.DP-P, GV.PO-P, ID.RA-P] [SP 800-63-4 risk-proportionate identity proofing] Contrary: expands collection of identity and address without minimization, retention rules or recourse
Disclosure of violent partners' criminal records and increased monitoring «en rendant disponibles les antécédents judiciaires des conjoints violents, en renforçant leur surveillance» [QS p.28, Bloc 6 Mesure 4 «Protéger les droits des femmes et l'accès à l'avortement», ¶3, s1] [PF CT.PO-P, CM.AW-P] [SP 800-53 PT-2, PT-3] Contrary: no recipients, trigger, retention or disclosure log
Police technology and registry of criminal organizations «Mieux équiper technologiquement nos services de police.» [PQ p.78, §5.5 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :», b7]; «Créer un registre des organisations criminelles.» [PQ p.79, §5.5 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :» (introduction p.78), b12] [PF ID.RA-P, CT.PO-P] [AI RMF MAP 5.1 if analytics] Not addressed; flagged: unspecified tools and a new state data store
«Unique» citizen digital identity «identité numérique unique et sécurisée pour chaque citoyen» [PQ p.25, §3.5 «D'identité et culture numériques», b1] [SP 800-63-4 pairwise pseudonymous identifiers] [PF CT.DP-P] Partial; linkability tension

[NIST §5]5. Review by party

Logo: Parti Québécois5.1 PQ: «Projet national» (90 pp.)

Statement (quote) Reference NIST ref. Verdict Technical note
«Créer une agence dédiée, Cyberdéfense Québec, pour protéger les infrastructures critiques et lutter contre les cybermenaces.» [PQ p.24, §3.5 «De cyberdéfense et gouvernance numérique», b1] [CSF 2.0 GV.RR-02, GV.RR-03, ID.AM-05] [SP 800-61r3] [SP 800-82r3] Partial (named owner) The only named cyber agency across all platforms. It has no mandate over operators, no reporting obligation, no budget and no timeline.
«Augmenter les ressources de la Commission d'accès à l'information (CAI)» [PQ p.24, §3.5 «De cyberdéfense et gouvernance numérique», b2] [PF GV.PO-P5, GV.MT-P7] Partial (named owner) Resources only; no powers and no indicators.
«Prioriser l'hébergement des données numériques sur le territoire québécois.» [PQ p.24, §3.5 «…structurera plusieurs efforts en matière :», b4]; with «pour garantir la protection des données sensibles» [PQ p.24, §3.5 «…structurera plusieurs efforts en matière :», b3] [CSF 2.0 PR.DS-01, GV.SC-05] [SP 800-53 SC-28, SC-12, SA-9(5)] Partial Localization stands in for protection [PQ pp.1–90 : 0 occurrence «chiffr»].
«identité numérique unique et sécurisée pour chaque citoyen» [PQ p.25, §3.5 «D'identité et culture numériques», b1] [SP 800-63-4 IAL/AAL/FAL] [CSF 2.0 PR.AA-02] [PF PR.AC-P6, CT.DP-P1] Partial; flagged No assurance level, no phishing-resistant option, no pairwise identifier and no offline alternative [PQ pp.1–90 : 0 occurrence «authentif», «pseudonym»].
«Promouvoir l'intégration de solutions d'IA développées au Québec dans les services publics (santé, éducation, justice)» [PQ p.23, §3.4 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :», b4] [AI RMF MAP 5.1, GOVERN 3.2, MEASURE 2.11, MANAGE 4.1] Not addressed High-impact public-sector AI with no impact assessment, bias testing, monitoring or decommissioning.
Strengths
Weaknesses

Logo: Coalition Avenir Québec5.2 CAQ: 2026 campaign pages

Statement (quote) Reference NIST ref. Verdict Technical note
«Une équipe relevant directement de la première ministre réunira l'expertise nécessaire pour les suivre du début à la fin.» [CAQ-2026-09-02, «En finir avec le fax», ¶1, s3] [CSF 2.0 GV.RR-01, GV.OV-03] [SP 800-37r2] Partial An owner at the highest level across the whole life cycle, but no authorization step and no security acceptance criteria.
«veiller à mieux protéger les données des Québécois» [CAQ-2026-09-02, «En finir avec le fax», ¶1, s5] [CSF 2.0 PR.DS] [PF GV.PO-P, PR.DS-P] Partial An owner is designated; no controls, classification or incident obligations.
«Le recours à l'intelligence artificielle sera également accéléré pour automatiser certaines tâches répétitives» [CAQ-2026-09-02, «S'attaquer à la paperasse et aux dédoublements», ¶2, s2] [AI RMF MAP 1.1, GOVERN 3.2, MEASURE 2.10] Partial Human judgment is retained for staff, but there is no inventory, no testing and no privacy impact assessment.
«Les services essentiels et les secteurs stratégiques resteront sous la responsabilité du secteur public… données sensibles» [CAQ-2026-09-02, «Mettre l'État au défi de faire mieux», ¶2, s4] [CSF 2.0 ID.AM-05, GV.SC] [SP 800-53 RA-9] Partial The right boundary, but «données sensibles» (sensitive data) is not defined.
Two police technology hubs; «14 M$ sur quatre ans» [CAQ-2026-09-12, «S'attaquer au crime qui se déplace en ligne», ¶1, s1, s3] [CSF 2.0 RS.AN (analogy), GV.RR-03/-04] Aligned (capability) A resourced police capability. It is not an organizational incident response, and oversight is absent (§4).
«d'inviter systématiquement les personnes admissibles, d'automatiser les rappels et de mieux suivre les résultats» [CAQ-2026-09-26, «Aller plus loin grâce à de meilleurs outils», ¶1, s1–s2] [CSF 2.0 ID.AM-07, PR.DS] [PF ID.IM-P, CT.DM-P, CM.AW-P] [SP 800-53 RA-8] Not addressed An automated IT project using health data for cancer screening, with no privacy impact assessment, notice or security [CAQ-2026-09-26, page entière : 0 occurrence «vie privée», «sécurité», «confidentialité»; 3 passages].
Strengths
Weaknesses

Note: the CAQ's 2026-02-13 page on digital sovereignty [CAQ-2026-02-13, «Accroître la souveraineté numérique du Québec», ¶2] presents a government policy, not a campaign commitment. It is excluded from the score ↔ [SP 800-53 SA-9(5)].

Logo: Parti libéral du Québec5.3 PLQ: commitments and fiscal framework

Statement (quote) Reference NIST ref. Verdict Technical note
«Faire du ministère de la Cybersécurité et du Numérique (MCN) le responsable central de la transformation numérique gouvernementale» [PLQ-E, «Transformation numérique», b1] [CSF 2.0 GV.RR-01, GV.RR-02, GV.RR-03, GV.OV] Aligned Gives the MCN legal and budgetary authority. The security mandate is not specified.
«Structurer les contrats de manière à permettre à l'État de changer de fournisseur sans se retrouver captif» [PLQ-E, «Transformation numérique», b4, s1] [CSF 2.0 GV.SC-10, GV.SC-05] [SP 800-53 SR-5, SA-4] Aligned (GV.SC-10) The only commitment on exit provisions across all platforms (with the SIFA example, b4, s2). Terms covering supplier incidents and breaches are absent (GV.SC-08).
MCN opinions «pour tout projet de plus de 25 millions de dollars seront également rendus publics» [PLQ-E, «Transformation numérique», b5, s2] [CSF 2.0 GV.OV-01..03] [SP 800-37r2] Aligned A threshold-based transparency mechanism. No rule for redacting security-sensitive details.
«Mettre en place une plateforme de télésanté.» [PLQ-E, Santé › «Faciliter l'accès aux soins de première ligne», b1, s1]; [PLQ-CF p.5, Tableau 3, ligne «Mise en place d'une plateforme de télésanté»] [CSF 2.0 PR.AA-01..03, PR.DS] [SP 800-63-4] [PF PR.AC-P, CT.DM-P] Not addressed No patient authentication level, no confidentiality and no privacy impact assessment.
«règles strictes… de protection des mineurs» for accredited online gambling («jeu en ligne») platforms [PLQ-E, Moderniser l'État › «Mieux encadrer les jeux en ligne et les marchés prédictifs», b2] [SP 800-63-4] [PF CT.DM-P] Partial No age verification method is mentioned (see §4).
«utilisation accrue de l'IA» against tax evasion and cybercrime [PLQ-CF p.4, Tableau 2, ligne «Lutte à l'évasion fiscale et la cybercriminalité»; phrase ≈p.3] [AI RMF MEASURE 2.10, 2.11, GOVERN 3.2] Partial (capability) / Not addressed (AI governance) No safeguard regarding bias, privacy or human review.
Strengths
Weaknesses

Logo: Parti conservateur du Québec5.4 PCQ: «Document technique – Plateforme numérique» (11 pp.)

Statement (quote) Reference NIST ref. Verdict Technical note
«La sécurité des données et des systèmes doit être intégrée dès leur conception et pendant toute leur durée de vie.» [PCQ p.11, Annexe 4 – principe 9, s1] [CSF 2.0 PR.PS-06, ID.AM-05/-08] [SP 800-218] Partial The best security principle of any party (by design, across the whole life cycle, proportionality with s2). No owner, standard or indicator.
«Aucune solution majeure ne sera déployée à grande échelle sans avoir d'abord été testée et validée dans des conditions réelles.» [PCQ p.3, Axe 3 – eng. 2, s2] [SP 800-37r2 Assess/Authorize] [SP 800-53 CA-2, CA-6] [CSF 2.0 ID.IM-02] Partial A genuine gate, but its test criteria exclude security [PCQ p.11, Annexe 4 – principe 2, s1].
«Les contrats de partenariat (partenariat public-privé) seront permis et favorisés pour les projets numériques» [PCQ p.4, Axe 3 – eng. 4, s1] [CSF 2.0 GV.SC-05/-06/-08/-10] [SP 800-161r1] Not addressed (increases risk) Long-term risk sharing with the private sector, with no clauses, audit or exit terms [PCQ pp.1–11 : 0 occurrence «clause», «audit»].
«des analyses d'impact allégées pour les petites entreprises» [PCQ p.2, Axe 1 – eng. 2, s3] [PF ID.RA-P] [SP 800-53 RA-8] Contrary The depth of the assessment depends on company size, not on data risk.
«guichet unique numérique pour plusieurs services» [PCQ p.7, Annexe 2, 2028-29 •2] [SP 800-63-4 IAL/AAL/FAL] [CSF 2.0 PR.AA-01..05] [PF CT.DP-P] Not addressed No identity assurance, resilience or unlinkability [PCQ pp.1–11 : 0 occurrence «identité», «authentif»].
«Tout déploiement d'IA devra respecter une gouvernance éthique stricte… supervision humaine obligatoire sur les décisions à fort impact» [PCQ p.3, Axe 3 – eng. 1, s5] [AI RMF GOVERN 1.2, GOVERN 3.2, MAP 5.1] Partial «Fort impact» (high impact) has no classification method.
Strengths
Weaknesses

Logo: Climat Québec5.5 Climat Québec: «Programme du parti» (2022, 24 pp.)

Clause 5.19 is a single sentence, so its parts are cited by the position of the proposal within it.

Statement (quote) Reference NIST ref. Verdict Technical note
«l'État priorisera l'utilisation de logiciels libres et ouverts» [Climat 2022 p.22, ch.5, cl. 5.19, s1 (1re proposition)] [CSF 2.0 GV.SC, PR.PS-06] [SP 800-218] Partial (GV.SC) A preference only; no security practice for open-source software, so PR.PS is not credited (§6).
«sera propriétaire des infrastructures entreposant ses bases de données» [Climat 2022 p.22, ch.5, cl. 5.19, s1 (2e proposition)] [PF ID.DE-P] [CSF 2.0 GV.SC-10, PR.IR] [SP 800-53 SA-9(5)] Partial Ownership, but no security, resilience or backup requirement.
«développera son expertise interne» [Climat 2022 p.22, ch.5, cl. 5.19, s1 (3e proposition)] [CSF 2.0 GV.RR-04] [SP 800-181r1] Partial No secure development practice.
«Rendra l'internet haute vitesse disponible dans toutes les régions» [Climat 2022 p.21, ch.5, cl. 5.16.d] [CSF 2.0 PR.IR] Not addressed Access only; no resilience.
Strengths
Weaknesses

Logo: Québec solidaire5.6 QS: «Plateforme électorale 2026» (35 pp.)

Statement (quote) Reference NIST ref. Verdict Technical note
«tout en améliorant la protection à laquelle ces personnes ont droit, notamment en anonymisant les dossiers» [QS p.10, Bloc 2 Mesure 3 «Mieux protéger les locataires» (titre p.9), ¶1 (pp.9–10), s3] [PF CT.DP-P2] [SP 800-188] Aligned A named body (the TAL), a dataset and a technique. The only mechanism-level privacy measure across all platforms, though narrow in scope.
«un cadre réglementaire concernant ces technologies basé sur les principes de transparence» (+ privacy, intellectual property) [QS p.33, Bloc 7 «Encadrer l'intelligence artificielle et protéger notre souveraineté numérique», ¶1, s2] [AI RMF GOVERN 1.1, 1.2; MEASURE 2.8, 2.10, 2.12] Partial The most complete list of trustworthy AI principles; no owner and no testing.
«Il maintiendra l'humain au cœur du système malgré le virage numérique.» [QS p.33, Bloc 7 «Encadrer l'intelligence artificielle…», ¶1, s3] [AI RMF GOVERN 3.2, MAP 3.5] Partial No decision categories and no appeal.
«leurs données personnelles soient protégées et stockées au Québec» [QS p.33, Bloc 7 «Encadrer l'intelligence artificielle…», ¶3, s1] [CSF 2.0 PR.DS-01/-02, GV.SC-05] [SP 800-53 SA-9(5)] Partial Protection through localization only.
«politiques publiques visant à freiner les discours masculinistes» [QS p.28, Bloc 6 Mesure 4 «Protéger les droits des femmes et l'accès à l'avortement», ¶2, s1] [PF CT.DP-P, CM.AW-P] [AI 600-1 Information Integrity] Partial; flagged See §4.
Strengths
Weaknesses

Logo: Parti vert du Québec5.7 PVQ: «Le Nouveau Plan VERT» (80 pp.)

Statement (quote) Reference NIST ref. Verdict Technical note
«un programme qui permettrait de voter par anticipation sur internet» [PVQ p.44, «Le vote par anticipation sur internet», ¶2, s1] [NIST IR 7770] [VVSG 2.0 P9, P10] Contrary (CRITICAL) See the callout box in §4.
«un code unique par vote qui sera traçable et de manière anonyme» [PVQ p.44, «Le vote par anticipation sur internet», ¶2, s2] [VVSG 2.0 P10] [PF CT.DP-P] Contrary Traceable and anonymous, with no design; a coercion and receipt risk.
«mécanismes de vérification de l'âge, et des systèmes technologiques» [PVQ p.56, «ENCADRER LES JEUX VIDÉO ET LIMITER LE TEMPS D'ÉCRAN POUR LES JEUNES», ¶2, s2] [SP 800-63-4] [PF CT.DM-P, CT.DP-P] Contrary See §4.
«Les outils d'intelligence artificielle ne sont pas capables de comprendre parfaitement les nuances du langage» [PVQ p.46, «Intelligence artificielle, désinformation et liberté d'expression», ¶3, s2] [AI RMF MAP 5.1, MEASURE 2.11] [AI 600-1 Information Integrity] Aligned (MAP) Credited in §4.1.
«accélérera l'informatisation du système de justice afin de… faciliter l'accès aux dossiers» [PVQ p.49, «Moderniser le système judiciaire», ¶1, s1] [CSF 2.0 PR.AA-05, PR.DS] [PF PR.AC-P, CT.DM-P] Not addressed Broader access to court records with no least-privilege or confidentiality caveat.
Data centers must «publier leurs données de consommation d'électricité et d'eau» [PVQ p.15, «Moratoire de cinq ans sur les nouveaux centres de données, écotaxe et encadrement strict des installations existantes», ¶2, s2] [AI 600-1 Environmental] [AI RMF MEASURE 2.12] Aligned (indirect) A disclosure and targets mechanism, framed by AI-related demand (¶1, s1).
Strengths
Weaknesses

[NIST §6]6. NIST gaps common to all parties

A category is marked ✓ when at least one statement reaches Partial or better, and ✗ otherwise. The evidence for each ✓ and the search behind each ✗ follow the matrix.

CSF 2.0 category
Logo: Parti QuébécoisPQ
Logo: Coalition Avenir QuébecCAQ
Logo: Parti libéral du QuébecPLQ
Logo: Parti conservateur du QuébecPCQ
Logo: Climat QuébecClimat
Logo: Québec solidaireQS
Logo: Parti vert du QuébecPVQ
GV.OC Organizational context✓✗✗✓✗✓✗
GV.RM Risk management strategy✓✗✗✓✗✗✗
GV.RR Roles and authorities✓✓✓✓✓✓✓
GV.PO Policy✗✗✗✓✗✗✗
GV.OV Oversight✓✓✓✓✗✗✗
GV.SC Supply chain✓✓✓✓✓✓✗
ID.AM Asset management✓✓✓✓✓✗✗
ID.RA Risk assessment✓✗✗✗✗✗✗
ID.IM Improvement✗✓✓✓✗✗✓
PR.AA Identity, authentication, access✓✗✗✗✗✗✗
PR.AT Awareness and training✓*✗✗✓✗✗✓*
PR.DS Data security✓✓✓✓✗✓✗
PR.PS Platform security✗✗✗✓✗✗✗
PR.IR Infrastructure resilience✓✗✗✗✓✗✗
DE.CM Continuous monitoring✓ (physical)✗✗✗✗✗✗
DE.AE Adverse event analysis✗✗✗✗✗✗✗
RS.MA Incident management✗ⁱ✗✗✗✗✗✗
RS.AN Incident analysis✗✓*✗ⁱ✗✗✗✗
RS.CO Incident response reporting and communication✗✗✗✗✗✗✗
RS.MI Incident mitigation✗✗✗✗✗✗✗
RC.RP Incident recovery plan execution✗✗✗✗✗✗✗
RC.CO Incident recovery communication✗✗✗✗✗✗✗
Categories addressed / 22127611443
PF CT.DM-P Data processing management✗✗✗✓ (principle)✗✗✗ (Contrary)
PF CT.DP-P Disassociated processing✗ (Contrary)✗✗✗✗✓ (Aligned)✓ + Contrary
PF PR.AC-P Identity and access✓✗✗✗✗✗✗
PF GV.MT-P Monitoring and review✓✗✗✗✗✓*✗
AI RMF MEASURE (all)✓✗✓ (benefit only)✓ (generic test)✗✓ (principles)✓* (indirect)
  • * By analogy: public literacy is counted as PR.AT; police hubs as RS.AN; whistleblower channels as GV.MT-P; data center disclosure as MEASURE 2.12.
  • ⁱ The function scores 1 by implication (§3), but no statement names this category's outcome, so the cell is not counted.
  • Consistency with §3: every function scored 0 has no ✓ category. Every function scored ≥1 has at least one ✓ category, except the two ⁱ cases (PQ RS, PLQ RS). The PVQ's ✓ ID.IM now matches the PVQ's ID 1 (§3).
Evidence key: ✓ cells (CSF 2.0 ↔ reference)
Party ✓ categories ← reference(s)
Logo: Parti QuébécoisPQ (12) GV.OC ← [PQ p.23, §3.5 «La souveraineté numérique…», ¶1, s2]; [PQ p.24, §3.5 «La souveraineté numérique…», ¶2, s4]; [PQ p.21, §3.3 «Protéger la liberté d'expression au Québec», ¶3, s1] · GV.RM ← [PQ p.24, §3.5 «La souveraineté numérique…», ¶2, s3] · GV.RR ← [PQ p.24, §3.5 «De cyberdéfense et gouvernance numérique», b1–b2] · GV.OV ← [PQ p.20, §3.2 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :», b4, b8] · GV.SC ← [PQ p.24, §3.5 «…structurera plusieurs efforts en matière :», b4] · ID.AM ← [PQ p.23, §3.5 «La souveraineté numérique…», ¶1, s2]; [PQ p.24, «De cyberdéfense et gouvernance numérique», b1] · ID.RA ← [PQ p.21, §3.2 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :» (introduction p.20), b12]; [PQ p.24, «De cyberdéfense et gouvernance numérique», b1] · PR.AA ← [PQ p.25, §3.5 «D'identité et culture numériques», b1] · PR.AT* ← [PQ p.25, §3.5 «D'identité et culture numériques», b3] · PR.DS ← [PQ p.24, §3.5 «…structurera plusieurs efforts en matière :», b3] · PR.IR ← [PQ p.24, §3.5 «La souveraineté numérique…», ¶2, s1]; [PQ p.24, §3.5 «…structurera plusieurs efforts en matière :», b2] · DE.CM ← [PQ p.79, §5.5 «Le Parti Québécois aspire à :», b15]. Not credited: GV.PO, because the objective [PQ p.24, §3.5 «La souveraineté numérique…», ¶2, s3] is scored under GV.RM-01, not as a policy instrument; PR.PS, because open-source software [PQ p.24, §3.5 «…structurera plusieurs efforts en matière :», b5] is security-neutral.
Logo: Coalition Avenir QuébecCAQ (7) GV.RR ← [CAQ-2026-09-02, «En finir avec le fax», ¶1, s3] · GV.OV ← [CAQ-2026-09-02, «En finir avec le fax», ¶1, s2–s3] · GV.SC and ID.AM ← [CAQ-2026-09-02, «Mettre l'État au défi de faire mieux», ¶2, s4] · ID.IM ← [CAQ-2026-09-02, «En finir avec le fax», ¶1, s1–s2] · PR.DS ← [CAQ-2026-09-02, «En finir avec le fax», ¶1, s5] · RS.AN* ← [CAQ-2026-09-12, «S'attaquer au crime qui se déplace en ligne», ¶1, s1, s3].
Logo: Parti libéral du QuébecPLQ (6) GV.RR ← [PLQ-E, «Transformation numérique», b1] · GV.OV ← [PLQ-E, «Transformation numérique», b5] · GV.SC ← [PLQ-E, «Transformation numérique», b4; b3, s2] · ID.AM and PR.DS ← [PLQ-E, «Transformation numérique», b3, s1] · ID.IM ← [PLQ-E, Moderniser l'État › «Simplifier les façons de faire», b1].
Logo: Parti conservateur du QuébecPCQ (11) GV.OC ← [PCQ p.1, Constats, ¶3, s2]; [PCQ p.2, Axe 1, ¶1, s1] · GV.RM ← [PCQ p.2, Objectifs, b2] · GV.RR ← [PCQ p.2, Axe 2 – eng. 1, s2]; [PCQ p.11, Annexe 4 – principe 6, s1] · GV.PO ← [PCQ p.1, Vision, ¶4]; [PCQ p.11, Annexe 4 – principe 9, s1] · GV.OV ← [PCQ p.3, Axe 3 – eng. 3, s2–s3]; [PCQ p.8, Annexe 2, 2029-30 •5] · GV.SC ← [PCQ p.2, Axe 2, ¶2, s1]; [PCQ p.11, Annexe 4 – principe 8, s1–s2] · ID.AM ← [PCQ p.7, Annexe 2, 2026-27 •1] · ID.IM ← [PCQ p.3, Axe 3 – eng. 2, s2]; [PCQ p.8, Annexe 2, 2030-31 •4] · PR.AT ← [PCQ p.8, Annexe 2, 2029-30 •4] · PR.DS ← [PCQ p.1, Vision, ¶2, s3]; [PCQ p.2, Axe 1 – eng. 2, s2] · PR.PS ← [PCQ p.11, Annexe 4 – principe 9, s1]; [PCQ p.7, Annexe 2, 2027-28 •7]. Not credited: PR.IR, because [PCQ p.2, Axe 2, ¶2, s2] evokes continuity only in spirit; PR.AA, because [PCQ p.3, Axe 2 – eng. 3, s3] is an illustration of X-Road, not a commitment.
Logo: Climat QuébecClimat (4) GV.RR ← [Climat 2022 p.22, ch.5, cl. 5.19, s1 (3e proposition)] · GV.SC ← [Climat 2022 p.22, ch.5, cl. 5.19, s1 (1re proposition)]; [Climat 2022 pp.19–20, ch.5 «Pour que l'État reprenne le contrôle de nos services publics», ¶1, s3–s4] · ID.AM and PR.IR ← [Climat 2022 p.22, ch.5, cl. 5.19, s1 (2e proposition)]. Not credited: PR.PS, because the preference for open-source software includes no secure development practice (treated like the PQ's open-source software).
Logo: Québec solidaireQS (4) GV.OC, GV.SC and PR.DS ← [QS p.33, Bloc 7 «Encadrer l'intelligence artificielle et protéger notre souveraineté numérique», ¶3, s1] · GV.RR ← [QS p.32, Bloc 7 «Donner le pouvoir au peuple», ¶3, s1]. Not credited: ID.RA, because the whistleblower analogy [QS p.32, «Donner le pouvoir au peuple», ¶3, s1] is counted only for PF GV.MT-P.
Logo: Parti vert du QuébecPVQ (3) GV.RR and ID.IM ← [PVQ p.43, «Réparer la bureaucratie et améliorer les services publics», ¶2, s1] · PR.AT* ← [PVQ p.54, «Éducation civique, médiatique et numérique», ¶1, s1]; [PVQ p.55, «Santé, bien-être et autonomie personnelle», ¶1, s4].
Evidence key: ✓ cells in the PF and AI rows
Search behind the ✗ cells
  • Local PDFs (PQ, QS, PCQ, PVQ, Climat).
    • Method: accent- and case-insensitive regular expression run on the pdftotext output of each page. Both reading-order and layout modes were queried, because layout mode splits sentences across columns. PCQ p.11 was queried using the transcription of the charter. Every non-zero occurrence was read in context. The inventories in the working notes were used for semantic matches.
    • Common term list: “cyber”, “sécurité informatique/numérique”, “gestion des risques”, “politique de sécurité”, “audit”, “fournisseur”, “sous-trait”, “clause”, “inventaire”, “menace”, “vulnérab”, “amélioration continue”, “authentif”, “identité numérique”, “sensibilis”, “chiffr”, “crypt”, “sauvegarde”, “correctif”, “résilien”, “continuité”, “journalis”, “surveill”, “détect”, “anomal”, “incident”, “notification”, “signalement”, “crise”, “restaur”, “plan de reprise”.
  • PQ (pp.1–90).
    • 0 occurrences: “sécurité informatique/numérique”, “gestion des risques”, “politique de sécurité”, “audit”, “fournisseur”, “inventaire”, “amélioration continue”, “authentif”, “chiffr”, “sauvegarde”, “correctif”, “continuité”, “journalis”, “anomal”, “notification”, “signalement”, “restaur”.
    • Non-zero occurrences read in context: “cyber” 5 (all credited, pp.24–25). “Menace” 5, of which only “cybermenaces” on p.24 is credited. “Surveill” 3: p.7 is the Contrary item; pp.31 and 48 are outside IT. “Incident” 1 (p.78, organized crime). “Vulnérab” 11, “résilien” 7, “détect” 3, “sensibilis” 6 and “crise” 16 are all outside IT.
  • QS (pp.1–35).
    • 0 occurrences: all terms except those below.
    • Non-zero occurrences read in context: “audit” 1 (p.20, “auditives”). “Menace” 2, “vulnérab” 2, “résilien” 1, “restaur” 1, “crise” 9 and “clause” 1 (lease) are outside IT. “Surveill” 1 is the Contrary item on p.28.
  • PCQ (pp.1–11).
    • 0 occurrences: all terms except those below; also “identité”, “police”, “vote”.
    • Non-zero occurrences read in context: “cyber” 2 (credited: p.2 and p.11). “Fournisseur” 2 and “inventaire” 3 are credited. “Chiffr” 1 is “chiffre inventé” on p.9. “Surveill” and “détect”, 1 each, correspond to principle 4 on p.11 (public surveillance). “Amélioration continue” 3 is credited under ID.IM.
  • PVQ (pp.1–80).
    • 0 occurrences: “gestion des risques”, “politique de sécurité”, “fournisseur”, “inventaire”, “amélioration continue”, “authentif”, “identité numérique”, “anomal”, “notification”, “plan de reprise”.
    • Non-zero occurrences read in context, all outside IT: “cyber” 1 (p.55, cyberbullying). “Audit” 3 (p.23, mines). “Sous-trait” 3 (p.19). “Sauvegarde” and “continuité”, 1 each (p.24). “Correctif” 1 (p.40, housing). “Journalis” 5 (journalists). “Surveill” 10, none related to IT monitoring (p.46 concerns the Elections Canada call for tenders). “Détect” 2 (air sensors; Senate). “Incident” 1 (p.76, animals). “Signalement” 2 (housing; bullying at school). “Chiffr” 2 and “crypt” 3 (cryptocurrency mining). “Clause” 5 (consumer contracts; notwithstanding clause; leases).
  • Climat (pp.1–24).
    • 0 occurrences: “cyber”, “authentif”, “chiffr”, “incident”, “notification”, “journalis”, “sauvegarde”, “continuité”, “informatique”, “vie privée”, “intelligence artificielle”, “IA”.
    • Non-zero occurrences read in context, all outside IT: “inventaire” 2 (GHG inventory). “Fournisseur” 1 (fossil fuels). “Surveill” 1 (p.22, water quality). “Résilien” 1, “menace” 1, “vulnérab” 1, “crise” 20, “restaur” 2 and “clause” 1 (investor clauses).
  • CAQ (Web, ≈ unless otherwise noted).
    • Text checked: [CAQ-2026-09-02, page entière]: 0 occurrences of “cybersécurité”, “sécurité”, “vie privée”, “Loi 25”, “MCN”, “identité”, “incident”, “notification”, “surveill”.
    • [CAQ-2026-09-12, page entière (texte intégral vérifié)]: 0 occurrences of “surveillance”, “vie privée”, “données”, “encadrement”, “Commission d'accès”.
    • [CAQ-2026-09-26, page entière]: 0 occurrences of “vie privée”, “renseignements”, “sécurité”, “consentement”, “confidentialité” (3 passes).
    • About 45 other campaign pages were screened by keyword with a list of digital, cyber, AI and online terms (working notes §0.2; single-pass reviews are ≈).
  • PLQ (Web, ≈).
    • [PLQ-E, page entière]: 0 occurrences of “vie privée”, “renseignements personnels”, “Loi 25”, “protection des données”, “Commission d'accès”, “vérification de l'âge”, “identité numérique”, “réseaux sociaux”, “police”, and “cybersécurité” outside the ministry's name (passes of 2026-09-29 and 2026-09-30).
    • [PLQ-CF]: no security line beyond Table 2, p.4.
Universal gaps

[NIST §7]7. Audit caveats

  • Approximate evidence (≈):
    • CAQ: the 09-21 page (paragraph splitting differs between passes), the economic plan PDF and the Trois-Rivières PDF (single pass) are ≈. None of them contributes to a score. The 09-10 sentence used here (¶1, s2) was confirmed in a second word-for-word pass on 2026-09-30. The 09-26 wording matches across three passes; only its $217M total (not used here) comes from a single pass.
    • PLQ: several items are ≈.
      • The position of the buy-local bullet and the end of «Accès à la première ligne» b4 are uncertain.
      • The page of the financial framework's «réforme de l'État» sentence is p.2 in two passes, versus p.4 in earlier notes.
      • The page of the «utilisation accrue de l'IA» sentence is p.3 in the 2026-09-30 pass, versus p.4 in the notes. The Table 2 line is on p.4 in all passes.
    • Absence claims for web pages come from summarized keyword checks. Absence claims for the PDFs (PQ, QS, PCQ, PVQ, Climat) are exact regular-expression results.
  • Analogy-based (*) and implied (ⁱ) scores shift a total by 1 or 2 points: CAQ RS, PVQ PR and MEASURE, PQ and PLQ RS, as well as the ✓ PR.AT of the PQ and the PVQ and QS's ✓ GV.MT-P. Several inferences are labeled as such in §4 and §5: the reliable tracking implied by a cumulative quota, and the moderation implied by content bans.
  • Verdict counts follow the granularity of each source inventory (PCQ 62 rows; PVQ 26; PQ 52). Two split rows were counted once: the PLQ's AI-driven tax analytics as Partial, and PVQ p.44 s3–s4 as Contrary.
  • QS's gap count was recalculated from the enumerated list of categories (18 absent). The figure of 19 in the working-notes summary is inconsistent with that list.
  • NIST items cited from the notes and not re-retrieved in this pass:
    • NIST IR 7770 and VVSG 2.0, including the wording of Principle 10;
    • the control titles of SP 800-53r5;
    • SP 800-37r2, 800-61r3, 800-161r1, 800-181r1, 800-188 and 800-218, cited at the publication level.

    The CSF 2.0, Privacy Framework and AI RMF identifiers were verified in the NIST PDFs on 2026-09-29. Outbound requests to nist.gov were blocked on 2026-09-30, so the reference URLs were not re-verified.

  • Excluded from scoring:
    • the CAQ's 2026-02-13 page on digital sovereignty, which presents a government policy (including it would bring the CAQ's CSF to 8 and PF to 6);
    • the 2020 joint CISA/EAC/FBI/NIST guidance on ballot return, which is not an exclusively NIST publication;
    • party positions reported only in the press: the budget amount for the PLQ's Agence numérique, the AI «loi-cadre», the human accountability rule and the claim that the MCN oversees AI (0 occurrences on plq.org), as well as the CAQ's overhaul of the police act (0 occurrences on the CAQ page).
  • Audit log (2026-09-30):
    • Quotes and sources. All French quotes in §1 and §3 to §6 were re-matched against the source text as normalized substrings. Quotes from the local PDFs were matched against the pdftotext output of each page (in both modes) and against the transcription of PCQ p.11. CAQ quotes were matched against src_caq_0902.md, Appendix A of the notes and fresh WebFetch passes of the 09-12, 09-26 and 09-10 pages. PLQ-E and PLQ-CF quotes were matched against WebFetch passes from 2026-09-30. Result: 0 discrepancies, and every quote is 20 words or fewer.
    • References and pages. Every table row in §4, §4.2 and §5 was checked against the page text; ambiguous layouts (PVQ pp.29, 36, 43, 44, 46, 67) were checked against the page image. Corrections:
      • CAQ 09-12 ¶1 has 3 sentences, so «radicalisation» moved from s3 to s2 and «14 M$» from s4 to s3 (3 places).
      • The PVQ tribunal quote moved from ¶1 to ¶2, s1.
      • Sentences were added where they were missing: PVQ p.15 ¶2 s2, p.35 ¶2 s2, p.36 ¶2 s3, p.45 ¶1 s2, p.46 ¶3 s2 and ¶4 s1, p.55 ¶1 s4, p.67 ¶1 s3; QS p.28 ¶2/¶3 s1; CAQ «Réduire…» ¶2 s3–s4 and «Mettre l'État au défi…» ¶1 s1–s2.
      • The PCQ GV rationale in the notes cites Axe 1 eng. 1 s4; the text is s3.
      • PQ list introductions located on other pages are now indicated: p.21 b12 (introduction p.20), p.79 b12 (introduction p.78), p.14 (introduction p.12). The title of the QS measure on p.10 is indicated at p.9.
    • Relative references. The 18 relative references (“same”, “same heading”, “[b4]” alone, “[cl. 5.19]”, “[whole document]”) were replaced with full references. References to party documents rose from 91 to 417, including 41 absence references that name their terms, and ↔ NIST links rose from 49 to 166. Web absences now name the page and the terms, and PDF absences give the page range and the terms with no occurrences.
    • Sums and consistency. The 21 per-framework totals in §3 were recalculated, as were the verdict counts per party inventory and the per-column counts in §6 (12/7/6/11/4/4/3, unchanged). Changes:
      • The PVQ's ID went from 0 to 1 (CSF from 2 to 3) to match its ✓ ID.IM.
      • §1 and §3 now state that DETECT is empty in six documents, not seven, because PQ DE = 1.
      • The RS 1 scores of the PQ and the PLQ are marked ⁱ, with a ✗ⁱ explained in §6.
      • The AI bullet in §1 now states that five of the six parties that address AI promote it; the PVQ does not.
    • Remaining ≈: 7 items. These are the CAQ passes (09-21, economic plan and Trois-Rivières), the PLQ's buy-local position, the end of the PLQ's «Accès» b4 and the two PLQ-CF sentence pages (p.2/p.4; p.3/p.4). Web absence checks are also summarized rather than exact.

[NIST §8]8. Audit references

Party documents (sole source of evidence)
ID Document Pages / sections Location
Logo: Parti QuébécoisPQ Parti Québécois, «Projet national» 90-page PDF https://pq.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/PQ-PROPOSITION-PRINCIPALE-PROJET-NATIONAL.pdf
Logo: Québec solidaireQS Québec solidaire, «Plateforme électorale 2026» 35-page PDF (34 numbered + back cover) https://cdn.prod.website-files.com/6a58006e8d06c0d8d7cc521d/6ab01e99dcf871bb13392026_Plateforme.pdf
Logo: Parti conservateur du QuébecPCQ Parti conservateur du Québec, «Document technique – Plateforme numérique» 11-page PDF (p.11 = Annexe 4, Charte du numérique) https://conservateur.quebec/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/Plateforme_numerique_mise_en_page_PCQ.pdf
Logo: Parti vert du QuébecPVQ Parti vert du Québec, «Le Nouveau Plan VERT» 80-page PDF (PDF p.36 is numbered “37”) https://www.pvq.qc.ca/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/Programme-2026-Parti-VERT-du-Quebec.pdf
Logo: Climat QuébecClimat Climat Québec, «Programme du parti», adopted April 23, 2022 24-page PDF https://climat.quebec/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/Programme-Climat-Que%CC%81bec-2022.pdf
Logo: Coalition Avenir QuébecCAQ-2026-09-02 «L'Équipe Christine Fréchette poursuivra la modernisation de l'État» Web page, 4 subheadings https://coalitionavenirquebec.org/fr/blog/2026/09/02/lequipe-christine-frechette-poursuivra-la-modernisation-de-letat/
Logo: Coalition Avenir QuébecCAQ-2026-09-12 «L'Équipe Fréchette protégera mieux les Québécois face à la nouvelle criminalité» Web page, 4 subheadings. Checked against the full page text (2026-09-30): introduction ¶1–¶4, then 4 subheadings; ¶1 of «S'attaquer au crime qui se déplace en ligne» has 3 sentences (s1 hubs, s2 targets, s3 «14 M$ sur quatre ans»). The source prints «s'engage également a créer» (sic). https://coalitionavenirquebec.org/fr/blog/2026/09/12/lequipe-frechette-protegera-mieux-les-quebecois-face-a-la-nouvelle-criminalite/
Logo: Coalition Avenir QuébecCAQ-2026-09-10 «L'Équipe Fréchette veut mieux accompagner les travailleurs face aux transformations économiques» Web page https://coalitionavenirquebec.org/fr/blog/2026/09/10/lequipe-frechette-veut-mieux-accompagner-les-travailleurs-face-aux-transformations-economiques/
Logo: Coalition Avenir QuébecCAQ-2026-09-26 «L'Équipe Christine Fréchette misera sur le dépistage précoce pour sauver plus de vies» Web page https://coalitionavenirquebec.org/fr/blog/2026/09/26/lequipe-christine-frechette-misera-sur-le-depistage-precoce-pour-sauver-plus-de-vies/
Logo: Coalition Avenir QuébecCAQ other Campaign pages of 09-21 and 09-23; «Notre plan économique» PDF (p.11); «Engagements Trois-Rivières» PDF (p.5); 2026 financial framework (no digital terms) N/A 09-21: https://coalitionavenirquebec.org/fr/blog/2026/09/21/lequipe-frechette-mise-sur-les-forces-du-quebec-pour-batir-une-nation-plus-autonome-et-plus-forte/; 09-23: https://coalitionavenirquebec.org/fr/blog/2026/09/23/lequipe-frechette-investira-324-m-pour-ameliorer-la-sante-mentale-des-jeunes/; economic plan: https://coalitionavenirquebec.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/mep-plan-economique-85x11po-v4-sans.pdf; Trois-Rivières: https://coalitionavenirquebec.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/engagements-trois-rivieres.pdf; financial framework: https://coalitionavenirquebec.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/cadre-financier-v8-30-aout.pdf
Logo: Parti libéral du QuébecPLQ-E Parti libéral du Québec, Engagements Web page (sections: L'économie; Moderniser l'État; Santé; Transformation numérique; Encadrement de l'IA) https://plq.org/engagements/
Logo: Parti libéral du QuébecPLQ-CF PLQ, Cadre financier 2026-2027 à 2030-2031 (Sept. 13, 2026) PDF; Table 2 p.4, Table 3 p.5 https://plq.org/PLQ_Cadre_financier.pdf
NIST publications (sole benchmark)
Publication Use URL
NIST CSWP 29, Cybersecurity Framework 2.0 (Feb. 26, 2024) Functions, 22 categories, subcategories, tiers https://nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/CSWP/NIST.CSWP.29.pdf
NIST CSWP 01162020, Privacy Framework 1.0 (Jan. 16, 2020) ID-P, GV-P, CT-P, CM-P, PR-P https://www.nist.gov/privacy-framework
NIST AI 100-1, AI Risk Management Framework 1.0 (Jan. 2023) GOVERN, MAP, MEASURE, MANAGE https://nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/ai/NIST.AI.100-1.pdf
NIST AI 600-1, Generative AI Profile (July 2024) The 12 generative AI risks (Information Integrity, Data Privacy, etc.) https://nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/ai/NIST.AI.600-1.pdf
NIST SP 800-63-4, Digital Identity Guidelines (2025) IAL/AAL/FAL, proportionality, minimization, pairwise identifiers https://csrc.nist.gov/pubs/sp/800/63/4/final
NIST SP 800-53 Rev. 5 SA-4, SA-9(5), SR-5/-6/-8, RA-8/-9, PT-2/-3, AU-2/-6, CA-2/-6, CM-7, SC-12/-28 https://csrc.nist.gov/pubs/sp/800/53/r5/upd1/final
NIST IR 7770, Security Considerations for Remote Electronic UOCAVA Voting (2011) Internet voting https://csrc.nist.gov/pubs/ir/7770/final
VVSG 2.0 (EAC/NIST, 2021) Principles 9 (auditability) and 10 (ballot secrecy) https://www.eac.gov/voting-equipment/voluntary-voting-system-guidelines
NIST SP 800-37r2 (RMF) Assess and authorize before deployment https://csrc.nist.gov/pubs/sp/800/37/r2/final
NIST SP 800-61r3 (incident response, CSF 2.0 profile) Implementing RS/RC https://csrc.nist.gov/pubs/sp/800/61/r3/final
NIST SP 800-161r1 (C-SCRM) Supply chain https://csrc.nist.gov/pubs/sp/800/161/r1/upd1/final
NIST SP 800-218 (SSDF) Secure development, open-source components https://csrc.nist.gov/pubs/sp/800/218/final
NIST SP 800-188 (de-identification of government datasets) Anonymization, public registries https://csrc.nist.gov/pubs/sp/800/188/final
NIST SP 800-82r3 (OT security) Critical infrastructure https://csrc.nist.gov/pubs/sp/800/82/r3/final
NIST SP 800-181r1 (NICE) Workforce https://csrc.nist.gov/pubs/sp/800/181/r1/final

Methodology

This site compares what the parties write in their own documents about cybersecurity, privacy, public safety, digital sovereignty and artificial intelligence. It does not judge the parties as a whole.

  1. 1

    Document collection

    Only the electoral platforms, commitment pages, financial frameworks and campaign pages published by the parties are used. Positions reported only by the media are not included. See the sources.

  2. 2

    Reading and identification

    Each document was read, then a keyword search (cyber, incident, encryption, authentication, privacy, AI, etc.) was used to confirm whether a topic is present or absent. Each finding refers to the page, section and paragraph of the original document. The Party proposals section describes what each party proposes, and the NIST audit scores it.

  3. 3

    Coding of commitments

    In the side-by-side comparison, each commitment is coded Specific (mechanism, amount or target), Vague (principle or intention) or None (no documented commitment).

  4. 4

    Comparison with NIST frameworks

    The commitments are then compared with NIST CSF 2.0, the NIST Privacy Framework 1.0 and the NIST AI RMF 1.0, scored from 0 to 4 per function, with a verdict per statement (Aligned, Partial, Not addressed, Contrary). See the NIST audit method.

  5. 5

    Review

    All content was reviewed by several cybersecurity professionals, each with more than ten years of experience in defensive and offensive security.

Possible errors

Despite this review, errors or omissions remain possible: a commitment may appear on a page that was not examined, a document may have been updated after it was consulted, or an interpretation may be open to debate. The links to each original document make it possible to verify every finding. See also the caveats.

Caveats

  • Savings figures: all savings figures (PCQ $3.45 billion) are the parties' own projections, not independent estimates.
  • Sources: only the parties' own documents and websites are cited. Positions reported only by the media are not included.

Sources

Findings about the parties cite only their own documents and websites. One public body source is used only for context in the analysis.

LegendOfficial platformthe party's electoral platform documentOfficial party documentanother official party publication

Coalition avenir Québec (CAQ)

Back to top of page